A Journal of the Expedition to Carthagena, with Notes Informative Summary

Overview:

This 1741 journal recounts the British expedition to Carthagena, a major military operation that ultimately ended in failure. The text provides a detailed account of the events, starting with the fleet’s departure from Jamaica and culminating in the retreat of the British forces. Key aspects of the expedition covered in the journal include the capture of Boca Chica Castle, the failed assault on Fort St. Lazar, the growing sickness among the troops, and the controversial role of the British navy in the campaign.

The journal offers a critical analysis of the expedition, highlighting the challenges the British faced, including the difficult terrain, the fierce Spanish resistance, and the debilitating heat and disease. The text also points to the lack of cooperation and coordination between the army and navy, ultimately leading to the expedition’s downfall.

Key Findings:

The capture of Boca Chica Castle was a significant British victory, but it ultimately proved to be a Pyrrhic one.
The assault on Fort St. Lazar was a costly failure, resulting in heavy casualties and demoralizing the British forces.
The expedition faced significant challenges from the Spanish, who were well-fortified and resilient.
The harsh climate and rampant disease proved to be formidable foes, taking a heavy toll on the British troops.
The lack of effective coordination between the army and navy significantly hindered the expedition’s success.

Learning:

The Importance of Coordination: This journal underscores the critical role of coordination between land and sea forces in successful military campaigns. The lack of clear communication and cooperation between the army and navy hampered the British efforts at Carthagena.
- Details: The journal highlights instances where the navy refused to support the army’s requests for reinforcements and assistance in crucial moments, ultimately contributing to the expedition’s failure.
The Impact of Disease and Climate: The journal emphasizes the devastating impact of disease and the harsh climate on military campaigns. The tropical heat and sickness greatly reduced the effectiveness of the British troops, impacting their ability to fight effectively.
- Details: The journal provides a graphic account of the escalating sickness among the troops, culminating in a decision to retreat due to the overwhelming number of casualties.
The Complexity of Siege Warfare: The journal sheds light on the complex challenges of siege warfare, highlighting the need for meticulous planning, skilled engineers, and adequate resources. The British faced difficulties in both establishing a strong position and achieving their objectives against a determined enemy.
- Details: The text provides detailed accounts of the various attempts by the British to establish batteries and attack the Spanish fortifications, illustrating the difficulties they encountered.

Historical Context:

The expedition to Carthagena took place during the War of Jenkins’ Ear, a conflict between Britain and Spain that escalated into a wider war. The British were seeking to capture Spanish colonies in the New World, hoping to gain strategic advantage and valuable resources. The expedition was seen as a crucial test for the British military, particularly in light of the recent peacetime period.

Facts:

The expedition was led by General Wentworth and Admiral Vernon.
The fleet left Jamaica in January 1741, aiming to capture Carthagena from the Spanish.
The initial objective was to capture Boca Chica Castle, which defended the entrance to the harbor.
The British successfully captured Boca Chica Castle on March 9, 1741.
The British attempted to capture Fort St. Lazar on April 9, but the attack was unsuccessful.
The British were ultimately forced to retreat from Carthagena due to disease, heavy casualties, and lack of supplies.
The main fortifications of Cartagena were considered very strong and well-defended.
The Spanish had a large garrison in Cartagena, which outnumbered the British forces.
The climate and terrain in the Caribbean presented significant challenges for the British troops.
The British troops suffered from numerous diseases, including yellow fever, malaria, and dysentery.
The capture of Boca Chica Castle was seen as a major British victory, but it was ultimately a Pyrrhic one.
The British were not able to land their artillery and other heavy equipment until after the capture of Boca Chica.
The assault on Fort St. Lazar was a costly failure for the British, resulting in heavy casualties.
The British were not able to establish a strong base of operations on land due to the difficult terrain.
The lack of adequate supplies and medical care contributed to the British losses.
The British navy played a controversial role in the expedition, with some arguing they did not provide adequate support to the army.
The expedition exposed weaknesses in the British military, prompting reforms and improvements in training and logistics.
The failure at Carthagena had a significant impact on British morale and strategic planning.
The War of Jenkins’ Ear ultimately proved to be a costly and ultimately unsuccessful conflict for Britain.
The British expedition to Carthagena is considered a significant event in the history of British-Spanish relations.

Statistics:

The British fleet consisted of over 200 ships, including warships and transports.
Over 10,000 British troops participated in the expedition.
The Spanish garrison at Cartagena numbered around 4,000 men.
The British suffered over 2,000 casualties during the expedition, mostly due to disease.
Only about 3,200 British troops remained fit for duty by the time of the retreat.
The British lost 179 men killed and 459 wounded in the assault on Fort St. Lazar.
The British were only able to land about 4,340 men at La Quinta, significantly less than the 5,000 they requested.
The British captured over 300 Spanish prisoners during the expedition.
The expedition cost the British government millions of pounds.
The British navy lost one ship, the Galicia, during the expedition.
Over 200 bombs were fired from the British mortar batteries at Fort St. Lazar.
The British were able to land 12 twelve-pounders and 3 three-pounders at La Quinta.
The British landed over 100 baulks and 300 battery planks for constructing their fortifications.
The British were able to capture and destroy two small batteries on the Passa-Cavallos.
The British were able to capture Castillo Grande with little resistance.
The British were able to open a passage for their bomb vessels and two twenty-gun ships through the channel leading to the Surgidero.
The British used seven galleons as a blockade in the channel leading to the Surgidero.
The British landed 100 soldiers as a garrison in Castillo Grande.
The British lost six men killed and 56 wounded when the Galicia was bombarded.
The British lost over 100 baulks and 300 battery planks during the expedition.

Terms:

Coupure: A trench or ditch dug to disrupt enemy movements or communications.
Fascine: A bundle of brushwood used for reinforcement or construction of fortifications.
Epaulement: A protective earthen rampart built to shield soldiers or artillery from enemy fire.
Mortar: A type of artillery that fires high-angle projectiles.
Cohorn: A small mortar used for close-range bombardment.
Embrasure: An opening in a fortification through which artillery is fired.
Platform: A raised structure designed to support artillery.
Barradera Battery: A Spanish battery situated on the Barradera side of the entrance to the harbor.
Lagoon: A body of shallow water separated from the open sea.
Surgidero: The main harbor of Cartagena.

Examples:

The Capture of Boca Chica Castle: The British successfully attacked and captured Boca Chica Castle after heavy bombardment by their warships. This victory was significant as it opened the way for the British to advance further into the harbor.
The Assault on Fort St. Lazar: The British attempted to capture Fort St. Lazar by a surprise assault, but the attack failed due to miscommunication and the enemy’s defenses. The British suffered heavy casualties, including the death of Colonel Grant.
The Lack of Naval Support: The British army frequently requested reinforcements and support from the navy, but these requests were often denied or delayed, hindering the army’s ability to make significant progress.
The Effects of Disease: The journal describes how the British troops suffered from rampant disease, particularly yellow fever and malaria. The sick and wounded were often sent back to Jamaica on transports.
The Importance of Intelligence: The British initially lacked adequate intelligence about the Spanish defenses, which led to some tactical errors and unexpected challenges.
The Role of the Guides: The British relied on Spanish deserters as guides during their operations, and these guides were not always reliable. The attack on Fort St. Lazar was hampered by a guide who misdirected the troops, leading to casualties.
The Difficult Terrain: The journal highlights the challenges faced by the British troops due to the difficult terrain and dense forests surrounding Cartagena.
The Need for Supplies: The expedition was plagued by shortages of supplies, including food, water, and medical supplies, which contributed to the troops’ difficulties and losses.
The Demoralization of the Troops: The failure of the attack on Fort St. Lazar and the increasing number of casualties led to demoralization among the British troops.
The Controversy Surrounding the Expedition: The journal is a primary source that offers insight into the internal conflicts and disputes that occurred between the army and navy during the expedition.

Conclusion:

This journal provides a valuable and critical look at the British expedition to Carthagena in 1741. The text vividly portrays the challenges the British troops faced, from the fierce Spanish resistance and the debilitating climate to the lack of effective coordination between the army and navy. The expedition ultimately ended in failure, highlighting the importance of proper planning, logistics, and coordination in military operations. The journal underscores the devastating impact of disease and the harsh realities of warfare, as well as the need for effective leadership and cooperation to achieve success.

Learn more