A Treatise on Staff Making and Pivoting Informative Summary

Overview:

This 1910 treatise, “A Treatise on Staff Making and Pivoting,” by Eugene E. Hall, delves into the intricate world of balance staff creation for watches. Hall emphasizes the high level of skill needed to produce a balance staff that not only looks beautiful but also functions flawlessly. He starts by outlining the importance of choosing the right steel and tempering it to a specific hardness, ensuring both durability and workability. Hall then guides the reader through the process of shaping the staff, covering the essential concepts of pivot construction, including the advantages of conical pivots over straight ones, and the importance of capillarity in oil retention. The text thoroughly explores the proper measurements, gauging methods, and the precise fitting of pivots to jewel holes, highlighting the need for careful side shake considerations. Hall delves into the intricacies of grinding and polishing, using various tools, including metal and boxwood slips and even an agate file, to achieve a flawless finish. He further instructs on the importance of a true wax chuck for secure staff mounting and offers a unique alternative using a brass tube and shellac. Hall concludes by exploring the art of pivoting, including the creation of hardening pivot drills, the drilling process, and the fitting of new pivots.

Key findings:

The Balance Staff is a Crucial Watch Component: Hall emphasizes the importance of the balance staff as a critical component in watchmaking, highlighting its role in regulating timekeeping.
Skill, Tools, and Precision are paramount: The text underscores that crafting a quality balance staff demands both meticulous craftsmanship and the use of appropriate tools for achieving accuracy in every step of the process.
Pivot Shape and Capillarity Matter: Hall explains the advantages of conical pivots over straight ones and emphasizes the significance of capillarity in oil retention and friction reduction.
Side Shake and Jewel Hole Accuracy are Essential: The treatise highlights the importance of proper side shake in pivot fitting and the need for accurate jewel hole measurements to ensure smooth watch operation.
Polishing Techniques Affect Performance: Hall delves into various grinding and polishing methods, emphasizing the need for meticulous surface preparation to eliminate graver marks and achieve a smooth, friction-reducing finish.
Pivot Drills Require Skill: The text details the creation and tempering of pivot drills, emphasizing the importance of using good quality steel, careful heating, and slow, deliberate drilling to avoid breakage.

Learning:

Balance Staff Construction: Readers will gain a detailed understanding of the processes involved in creating a balance staff, from material selection to pivot fitting.
Pivot Design and Function: The treatise explains the various types of pivots, highlighting the advantages of conical pivots for strength and size.
Capillarity in Watchmaking: Hall provides a clear explanation of capillarity and its role in oil retention, jewel hole design, and pivot shaping.
Precision Measurement and Gauging: The text delves into the crucial role of accurate measurement and the use of various tools, like pivot gauges and broaches, for ensuring the proper fit and function of the balance staff.
Grinding and Polishing Techniques: Readers will learn about the different techniques for grinding and polishing using metal and wood slips, as well as the benefits of using an agate file for a superior finish.
Pivot Drill Construction and Hardening: Hall provides a detailed guide to creating and hardening pivot drills, highlighting the importance of using high-quality steel and a careful tempering process.

Historical Context:

Interchangeable Parts and Cheap Materials: The text acknowledges the emerging trend of interchangeable parts and readily available materials in watchmaking. However, Hall firmly asserts that creating a new balance staff from scratch remains a valuable skill for watchmakers, particularly for dealing with older or less common movements.
The Importance of Watchmaking Skills: Hall underscores the importance of traditional watchmaking skills, emphasizing that watchmakers who do not possess the ability to create a balance staff are, essentially, apprentices or students, even if they work professionally.
The Rise of Standardized Measurements: Hall’s detailed guide to precise measurements suggests the increasing importance of standardization in watchmaking during this era.
Technological Advancements: The text mentions the “American-made lathe” and refers to “foreign-made lathes manufactured on American lines,” reflecting the significant advancements in machine tools and manufacturing techniques occurring in the early 20th century.

Facts:

Balance staffs are the most intricate turned watch components: The text emphasizes the complexity and skill required to manufacture balance staffs compared to other watch components.
Conical pivots are stronger and smaller than straight pivots: The shape of the conical pivot increases its strength while allowing for a smaller size.
Capillarity draws oil away from jewels: The attraction between oil and the material of the pivot can cause oil to be drawn away from the jewel, leading to reduced lubrication and increased friction.
The back-slope on conical pivots helps with oil retention: This design feature reduces the thickness of the pivot, preventing excessive oil from being drawn away.
The end stone in a jewel is convex to retain oil: The shape of the end stone facilitates the retention of oil between the jewel and the end stone, ensuring a continuous supply to the pivot.
A pivot should be 1/2500 of an inch smaller than the jewel hole for lubrication: This small gap allows for the proper application of oil and minimizes friction.
Side shake doesn’t increase proportionately with pivot size: While larger pivots require more side shake for oil movement, the increase is not linear.
The smallest pivots require a minimum side shake of 1/5000 of an inch on each side: This allows for sufficient movement of oil globules to ensure proper lubrication.
Long spiral coils indicate a properly cut graver: The ideal shavings from a graver should form long, spiral coils, indicating a clean and efficient cut.
Agate slips are effective for polishing: Agate slips, with their fine grain, are particularly well suited for achieving a final polish on balance staffs.
The balance seat should be slightly undercut to secure the balance: This design feature allows the balance to be tightly driven on, eliminating the need for riveting.
Pivot drills should be made from Stubb’s steel for strength and durability: Stubb’s steel provides a balance of hardness and flexibility, making it ideal for creating pivot drills.
Beeswax or sealing wax is used to harden pivot drills: The heat of the drill is quickly quenched by plunging it into wax, ensuring a consistent and controlled hardening process.
Mercury hardening makes the drill extremely hard but brittle: This method, while effective for penetrating hard steel, increases the brittleness of the drill, making it more susceptible to breakage.
Turpentine is used as a lubricant when drilling: Turpentine lubricates the drill, reducing friction and heat during the drilling process.
Alternating drill rotation prevents overheating: Rotating the drill in alternating directions helps to distribute heat more evenly, reducing the risk of temper loss in the drill.
Copper wire can be used to heat specific areas of the staff for temper reduction: This allows for controlled temper reduction in specific areas, minimizing the risk of damaging the overall staff.
Joints wires can help prevent cylinder breakage during pivoting: This method provides a secure and stable holding point for the cylinder during pivoting, reducing the risk of accidental breakage.

Statistics:

Stubb’s steel wire, No. 46, is recommended for balance staffs: This specific size is ideal for creating balance staffs, offering a balance of strength and workability.
The temper of a balance staff should be drawn down to 500°F for optimal hardness: This temperature ensures a balance between hardness and workability.
A pivot should be 1/2500 of an inch smaller than the jewel hole: This ensures a proper fit while allowing for lubrication.
A side shake of 1/2500 of an inch is sufficient for a pivot: This minimal gap allows for oil movement while minimizing play.
A balance staff may be shortened by 1/2500 of an inch: This provides an accurate adjustment for precise length settings.
The center of a wax chuck should be turned out at an angle of 60°: This angle creates a secure and stable point for holding the staff.
The V-shaped center for the wax chuck should be turned at an angle of 60°: This allows for a precise and stable point for attaching the staff.
A piece of brass tubing, slightly smaller than the taper chuck, is needed for the wax shell: This provides a secure fitting for the staff and allows for easy removal.
The hole for air release in the wax shell is drilled 1/4 inch from the end: This vent ensures the proper flow of shellac into the shell.
The taper chuck should be turned down to two-thirds of its original diameter: This creates a secure fitting for the brass shell.
A sewing needle, size 3 or 4, can be used to make a pivot drill: These needles provide a suitable material for creating pivot drills, although they may be less durable than larger wires.

Terms:

Balance staff: The component of a watch that carries the balance wheel and regulates the timekeeping function.
Pivot: The small, cylindrical or conical part of a balance staff that rotates in a jewel hole.
Capillarity: The tendency of a liquid to rise in a narrow tube or between closely spaced surfaces, due to the attraction between the liquid and the surface.
Side shake: The amount of clearance between a pivot and its jewel hole, allowing for oil movement and minimizing friction.
Jewel hole: The small, precisely drilled hole in a jewel that houses a balance staff pivot.
End stone: A small jewel that is positioned close to the jewel hole and aids in oil retention.
Graver: A small, pointed tool used for cutting and shaping metal in watchmaking.
Cement chuck: A type of lathe chuck that uses a cement-like substance to hold the work securely.
Wax chuck: A lathe chuck that uses wax to hold workpieces.
Poising: The process of adjusting the weight distribution of a balance wheel to ensure its proper operation.

Examples:

The use of a triangular piece of steel wire to demonstrate pivot and jewel hole accuracy: This example highlights the detrimental effects of imperfections in both the pivot and the jewel hole on watch performance.
The use of a needle to illustrate capillarity: The oil rapidly ascends the needle’s point, demonstrating the adhesive force between oil and the needle.
The comparison of a wax chuck to a cork in a bottle: This analogy helps to visualize the placement and function of the wax chuck.
The use of a degree gauge for measuring the balance staff length: The text provides a step-by-step guide for using a degree gauge to determine the correct length of the balance staff.
The construction of a wax shell using a brass tube and shellac: This example provides a practical and alternative method for securing the balance staff during pivoting.
The use of a joint wire to prevent cylinder breakage during pivoting: This example highlights a method for securely attaching the cylinder to a joint wire, reducing the risk of breakage during pivoting.
The use of a copper wire to reduce the temper of a staff: This example provides a targeted and controlled method for softening specific areas of the staff for easier drilling.

Conclusion:

This 1910 treatise provides a comprehensive guide to creating balance staffs, emphasizing the importance of meticulous craftsmanship, precise measurements, and the use of specialized tools. Hall stresses that crafting a balance staff is not simply a matter of following a set of steps but demands a deep understanding of the principles of watchmaking, including pivot construction, capillarity, and the effects of surface finish on performance. The text encourages watchmakers to strive for perfection in their work, highlighting the benefits of precision in achieving high-quality timepieces. The treatise serves as a valuable resource for both novice and experienced watchmakers, offering a detailed insight into the intricate world of balance staff construction and pivoting.

Learn more