Food in War Time Informative Summary

Overview:

This 1918 text, “Food in War Time,” written by Graham Lusk, Professor of Physiology at Cornell University Medical College, addresses the critical need for efficient and balanced diets amidst the wartime food shortage. Lusk argues against the unnecessary consumption of meat, highlighting the expense of its production and the availability of alternative and more efficient protein sources, such as milk, pork, and even vegetables. He also emphasizes the importance of prioritizing calorie awareness and utilizing calorie charts to understand the energy requirements of various activities and occupations.

Lusk draws on historical examples, such as the dietary practices of Italian peasants and English people during the reign of Queen Elizabeth I, to demonstrate the viability of meat-restricted diets and the potential of substituting more affordable and accessible food sources. He also utilizes scientific research and data to support his arguments, illustrating the caloric demands of various tasks and highlighting the consequences of overconsumption and the benefits of weight management. The text advocates for prioritizing the production of dairy products over beef and encourages the use of corn as a sustainable substitute for wheat.

Key Findings:

Meat is not essential for human health and well-being.
The production of meat is inefficient, requiring significant amounts of fodder that could be better utilized for producing milk and other protein sources.
Corn is a viable and affordable substitute for wheat, and its consumption can contribute to conserving wheat for export.
Calorie awareness is crucial for ensuring adequate nutrition and maximizing food resources.
Overweight individuals can contribute to food conservation by reducing their weight and minimizing their energy requirements.

Learning:

Understanding Calorie Needs: The text emphasizes the concept of calories and explains how they are used to measure the energy needed for various activities, from resting to working and exercising. This knowledge allows readers to make informed decisions about their food choices and ensure they meet their individual energy requirements.
Meat Consumption: Lusk argues that meat is not essential for health and well-being, highlighting the high cost of its production and the availability of alternative, more efficient protein sources. He emphasizes that meat consumption should be reduced, especially during times of food scarcity.
Balanced Diets: The text advocates for balanced diets that prioritize essential nutrients, particularly protein, which can be derived from sources other than meat. Lusk stresses the importance of including dairy products, vegetables, and grains in the diet, emphasizing the nutritional benefits of these alternatives.
Food Conservation: Lusk presents several strategies for food conservation, including reducing meat consumption, utilizing corn as a substitute for wheat, and prioritizing dairy production. This information encourages readers to make conscious choices to support wartime efforts and contribute to the well-being of the nation.

Historical Context:

This text was written in 1918, during World War I, a time marked by severe food shortages and rationing across Europe. The text reflects the anxieties and concerns surrounding food security, highlighting the need to prioritize efficient food consumption and minimize waste.

Facts:

Corn Saved New England Ancestors: Corn was a vital food source for early New England settlers, helping to prevent starvation. This demonstrates the importance of corn as a sustainable and reliable food source.
Green Leaves Are Essential: Green leafy vegetables are crucial for supplementing the protein in corn and providing essential vitamins and minerals, even more so than animal fats. This underscores the importance of vegetable consumption for a balanced diet.
Meat Does Not Increase Muscular Power: Contrary to popular belief, meat does not enhance muscle strength or athletic performance. This challenges a common misconception and encourages readers to consider alternatives for muscle-building.
Italian Peasants Thrived on a Meat-Free Diet: Italian peasants living on a diet of corn, olive oil, and green leaves have thrived for generations, demonstrating the viability of a meat-free diet. This provides a historical example of a successful meat-free dietary model.
Butter Is Not Essential: Butter, although traditionally consumed, is not a vital food source. This challenges traditional dietary norms and encourages the exploration of alternative fat sources like vegetable oils and margarine.
Oleomargarine Contains Fat-Soluble Vitamins: Oleomargarine, produced from beef fat, contains the fat-soluble vitamin necessary for growth, which is present in butter but absent in vegetable oils. This provides a scientific justification for the use of oleomargarine as a substitute for butter.
Milk Is the Cheapest Protein Food: Milk is an efficient and affordable source of protein, making it a more economical choice than meat. This encourages families to prioritize milk consumption.
Whole Milk Is More Important Than Butter: Whole milk provides a complete range of nutrients, including protein, fat, and vitamins, while cream, from which butter is made, represents a significant waste of milk. This highlights the importance of consuming whole milk for maximum nutritional benefit.
Meat Production Is Inefficient: The production of beef requires significantly more fodder than the production of milk or pork of the same nutritional value. This emphasizes the need to reduce beef consumption to conserve resources.
A Maximal Economic Hog: A pig weighing 150 pounds represents the most efficient use of feed resources for pork production. Beyond that weight, the cost of maintaining the animal outweighs the increase in food value. This highlights the importance of strategic livestock management for efficient food production.
Alcohol Decreases Work Capacity: Alcohol, while giving a false sense of energy, actually diminishes work capacity. This underscores the importance of abstaining from alcohol for optimal physical performance.
Overfat Individuals Can Conserve Food: Reducing body weight can significantly reduce an individual’s caloric needs, leading to food conservation. This encourages overweight individuals to prioritize weight management.
Carbohydrates Are the Primary Source of Energy: Carbohydrates, such as bread, corn, rice, and macaroni, provide the primary source of energy for work and physical activity. This emphasizes the importance of including carbohydrates in the diet.
Cane Sugar Is a Valuable Condiment: Cane sugar can help delay fatigue when consumed in small amounts. This encourages the use of sugar as a supplement to enhance performance.
Glucose Can Substitute for Sugar: Glucose, found in grapes and raisins and commercially produced as corn syrup, can effectively replace sugar, which is a valuable resource during wartime. This encourages the substitution of sugar with readily available alternatives.
The Importance of Eating Well: The text stresses the importance of properly cooked food and suggests that teaching girls how to cook can improve the overall health and well-being of families. This emphasizes the role of education and cooking skills in promoting healthy dietary habits.
Undernourished Workers Are Less Productive: Undernourished individuals may initially sustain work, but their performance deteriorates over time. This underscores the importance of ensuring adequate nutrition for a productive workforce.
Calorie Consumption Is Instinctive: People instinctively consume calories, often purchasing food by weight without considering its energy value. This highlights the need for better calorie education to empower consumers to make informed food choices.
Posture and Metabolism: Standing requires more energy than sitting, while carrying a load increases the energy needed even further. This provides a scientific basis for understanding the energy demands of various postures and activities.
The Energy Value of Food Is Important: The text emphasizes the importance of understanding the calorie content of various foods to make informed food choices and maximize food resources. This encourages a more mindful and strategic approach to food selection.

Statistics:

Only 6.6% of the Corn Crop is Used for Human Food: This highlights the potential of corn as a source of food and encourages its greater utilization.
3.4% of Corn is Consumed by Farmers and Families: This suggests that the majority of the corn crop is not directly used for human consumption, indicating potential for increased utilization for food purposes.
15% of German Milk Supply Was Used for Cream: This highlights the potential for a significant increase in whole milk availability by reducing the production of cream, a less efficient use of milk resources.
A Cow Produces More Protein and Calories Than its Body Weight: A well-nourished cow provides more protein and calories than its body weight in a year, highlighting the efficiency of dairy production as a source of food.
24% of Grain Energy is Recovered in Pork: Pork production is more efficient than beef production, recovering a higher percentage of grain energy for human consumption.
18% of Grain Energy is Recovered in Milk: Milk production is even more efficient than pork production, highlighting the importance of prioritizing milk production for maximizing food resources.
Only 3.5% of Grain Energy is Recovered in Beef and Mutton: Beef and mutton are the least efficient methods of recovering grain energy for human consumption. This emphasizes the need to minimize beef production and prioritize more efficient sources of protein.
10% of Family Income Spent on Drink: This highlights the potential for significant savings and improvements in family well-being by reducing alcohol consumption and allocating those funds to nutritious foods.
A Man Who Lost Nearly Half His Body Weight Needed 40% of Former Calories: This illustrates the significant reduction in calorie needs associated with weight loss, highlighting the potential for food conservation through weight management.
A 9-Pound Weight Gain in a Year from Excess Calorie Intake: This demonstrates the significant impact of even small excesses in calorie consumption over time. It encourages individuals to prioritize balanced calorie intake.
A Soldier on a Forced March Needs 4,022 Calories Per Day: This illustrates the significant energy requirements for physically demanding activities, emphasizing the importance of ensuring sufficient calorie intake for workers performing demanding tasks.
A Man Running 40 Miles Needs 5,433 Calories Per Day: This highlights the significant energy needs associated with high-intensity exercise, underscoring the importance of adequate calorie intake for athletes and individuals engaged in rigorous physical activities.
A Tailor Working 8 Hours a Day Needs 2,144 Calories Per Day: This provides a specific example of the calorie requirements for various occupations, illustrating the importance of tailoring food intake to the demands of different jobs.
A Seamstress Using a Sewing Machine Needs 24-57 Extra Calories Per Hour: This provides a specific example of the calorie requirements for different tasks within a profession, showing how specific activities can impact energy demands.
A Housemaid Needs 81-157 Extra Calories Per Hour: This highlights the significant energy requirements for physically demanding occupations, demonstrating the need for adequate calorie intake for workers in labor-intensive fields.
A Stonemason Needs 300 Extra Calories Per Hour: This emphasizes the high calorie needs for physically demanding jobs and encourages proper calorie intake to support individuals performing heavy manual labor.
A Man Sawing Wood Needs 378 Extra Calories Per Hour: This demonstrates the significant energy demands associated with specific activities, highlighting the importance of tailoring calorie intake to specific work requirements.
Cottonseed Oil Costs 7.3 Cents per 1000 Calories: This provides a specific example of the cost of various food sources based on their calorie content, empowering consumers to make informed decisions about their purchases.
Oleomargarine Costs 8.5 Cents per 1000 Calories: This provides a comparison of the costs of different fat sources, demonstrating the affordability of oleomargarine as an alternative to butter.
Cream Costs 37.7 Cents per 1000 Calories: This highlights the high cost of cream as a source of fat, encouraging the consumption of whole milk and other more affordable fat sources.

Terms:

Basal Metabolism: The minimum amount of energy the body needs to function at rest.
Calories: A unit of energy measured as the amount of heat required to raise one liter of water one degree Celsius.
Specific Dynamic Action: The increase in heat production caused by the body’s metabolism of protein.
Vitamins: Essential organic compounds needed in small amounts for growth, maintenance, and the proper functioning of the body.
Oleomargarine: A butter substitute made from vegetable oils and animal fats.
Pellagra: A disease caused by a deficiency of niacin, often associated with the consumption of diets high in corn and low in animal protein.
Maximal Economic Hog: A pig weighing 150 pounds, representing the most efficient use of feed resources for pork production.
Corn Syrup: A thick syrup produced from corn starch, often used as a substitute for sugar.
Vin Ordinaire: A common, inexpensive red wine from France.
Medico-Actuarial Investigation: A research project conducted in 1912 to study the health and mortality of American life insurance policyholders.

Examples:

Italian Peasants: The text describes the diet of Italian peasants who consume mainly cornmeal, olive oil, and green leaves, demonstrating the viability of a meat-free diet.
English People during Queen Elizabeth I’s Reign: The text describes the food habits of English people during the reign of Queen Elizabeth I, where wheat was reserved for the wealthy, while the poor consumed rye, barley, and even bean and pea bread, showcasing historical examples of food substitutions.
Yale’s Champion Athlete: The text mentions a Yale athlete who won all the events of the year while following a reduced protein diet, proving that meat is not essential for athletic performance.
The Clergyman or Physician: The text uses the example of a clergyman or physician who consumes slightly more calories than necessary to illustrate the potential for weight gain over time due to small excesses in food intake.
The Woman Who Lost Nearly Half Her Body Weight: The text cites the example of a woman who required only 40% of her former calories after significant weight loss, demonstrating the dramatic reduction in energy needs associated with emaciation.
The Overweight Man Who Lost 90 Pounds: The text mentions a man who lost a significant amount of weight during the war, highlighting the impact of food scarcity and government-imposed restrictions on weight management.
The Corpulent Professor: The text mentions a professor who lost weight during the war but gained it back during a summer vacation, illustrating the importance of sustained weight management efforts.
The American Woman Who Lost 40 Pounds in Dresden: This example highlights the widespread impact of the war on weight management and the potential for significant weight loss due to food rationing.
The Poor Woman Waiting for Fat: The text describes a poor woman who spent more calories standing in line for her fat ration than she received, emphasizing the importance of calorie considerations even during times of scarcity.
The Soldier on a Forced March: The text calculates the calorie needs of a soldier on a long hike, demonstrating the significant energy requirements for physically demanding activities.

Conclusion:

“Food in War Time” provides a compelling argument for prioritizing balanced diets, understanding calorie needs, and maximizing food resources during times of scarcity. The text challenges the traditional emphasis on meat consumption and highlights the availability and efficiency of alternative protein sources like milk, vegetables, and grains. Lusk emphasizes the importance of calorie awareness for both individuals and nations, encouraging readers to make conscious food choices to support wartime efforts and ensure the well-being of all. The text underscores the need for responsible food consumption, efficient production strategies, and a shift in perspective towards maximizing resource utilization for the benefit of individuals and society.

Learn more