John Jacob Astor Quiz Questions and Answers

How do you feel about Astor’s relentless pursuit of wealth?

I admire his ambition and drive.
It’s inspiring to see someone build such a fortune from scratch.
I have mixed feelings – success is great, but not at all costs.
It’s a reminder of the capitalist drive that often overshadows other values.

What’s your favorite anecdote about John Jacob Astor?

His encounter with Lewis and Clark, showing his thirst for new ventures.
The story of Mary Philipse’s land, highlighting the era’s business deals.
His joy at seeing people enjoy the Astor House, a testament to his vision.
I find his personal life less interesting than his business achievements.

What makes you nervous about Astor’s approach to business?

His ruthlessness in a competitive market seems intense.
The potential exploitation of Native Americans in the fur trade is concerning.
I worry about the environmental impact of industries like fur trapping.
Astor’s methods were typical of his time, so it’s hard to judge by today’s standards.

What makes you most frustrated about the way history remembers Astor?

He’s often reduced to his wealth, not his complexities.
The darker side of the fur trade is often glossed over.
I wish there were more personal accounts of him, not just business records.
History is what it is – we can’t change how people are remembered.

What are you most excited about when learning about Astor’s life?

Seeing how New York City evolved alongside his investments.
Understanding the fur trade’s significance in early America.
Discovering the man behind the millions – his passions and flaws.
I’m most interested in the economic systems he operated within.

What do you dream about when it comes to emulating Astor’s success?

Having that level of business acumen to spot opportunities.
Building a legacy that benefits generations, like the Astor Library.
I’m content with my own path, Astor’s story is simply interesting.
It’s unrealistic to compare ourselves to such a unique figure in history.

What happened in the past when Astor realized the potential of the fur trade?

He dedicated himself to learning from experienced traders.
He saw a chance to build wealth and independence for himself.
It sparked his ambition to create a vast and influential empire.
He was likely driven by both profit and a genuine interest in the field.

What comes to mind when you think about Astor’s real estate investments?

His incredible foresight in predicting the growth of cities.
The immense wealth he accumulated from owning prime properties.
The lasting impact he had on the landscape of New York City.
It seems like a risky strategy, but it obviously paid off enormously.

What’s your favorite example of Astor’s business acumen?

His meticulousness in details, like setting the price of beaver pelts.
His willingness to invest in unexplored territories for potential gain.
His ability to build relationships with diverse people, from Native Americans to elites.
His understanding of legal matters, as seen in the Morris estate case.

When you were a kid, how did you imagine people like John Jacob Astor?

As powerful figures, almost like characters in a history book.
As ruthless businessmen, only concerned with profit.
I wasn’t really aware of figures like him until much later.
I imagined them as adventurers, exploring new lands and opportunities.

You have a choice of inheriting Astor’s fortune or his business sense, which do you choose?

The fortune, of course! Who wouldn’t want that kind of wealth?
Business sense, as it’s the key to creating lasting success.
Neither, I’d rather make my own way in the world.
It’s a tough choice – both offer incredible advantages in life.

A specific situation arises: You’re offered a risky business deal with potential for high reward. How do you react?

Like Astor, I’d carefully analyze the risks and potential gains.
I’d be cautious, preferring safer investments over risky ventures.
I’d trust my gut instinct and take the risk if it felt right.
It would depend entirely on the specific details of the deal.

What keeps you up at night about the ethics of early American business practices?

The exploitation of indigenous populations for profit is disturbing.
The lack of regulations allowed for some questionable business tactics.
It’s hard to reconcile past actions with modern values and standards.
I try not to dwell on the past, as I can’t change it.

Which of these aspects of Astor’s life would you enjoy the most?

Negotiating fur deals with Native American tribes.
Strategically purchasing land and watching it rise in value.
Building and managing a grand hotel like the Astor House.
Funding a library and contributing to the advancement of knowledge.

When you think about Astor’s legacy, what are you most concerned about?

That his wealth came at the expense of others’ exploitation.
That his name is associated with a bygone era of business practices.
I’m more interested in the positive aspects of his legacy, like his philanthropy.
Every legacy has its complexities – it’s important to acknowledge both sides.

What aspect of Astor’s personality makes you the most happy?

His dedication to his goals, showing that hard work pays off.
His vision for the future, reminding us to think beyond the present.
His eventual philanthropy, using his wealth for a greater good.
I appreciate his complexities, both as a businessman and a person.

What is most likely to make you feel down about the realities of building a fortune like Astor’s?

The potential for greed and exploitation to overshadow ethical concerns.
The immense pressure and risk involved in such large-scale ventures.
The realization that such wealth is often built on the backs of others.
It’s a reminder of the inequalities inherent in capitalist systems.

In a perfect world, what would Astor’s legacy be remembered for?

His contributions to the growth of New York City and America.
His philanthropic endeavors and support for education.
A nuanced understanding of his achievements within their historical context.
Ideally, we can learn from both the positive and negative aspects of his life.

If you could waive a magic wand, what would the perfect outcome of the Astoria venture be?

It thrives as a sustainable trading post, benefiting both Astor and Native Americans.
It becomes a model for ethical trade and collaboration with indigenous populations.
Realistically, the historical context might make such an ideal outcome impossible.
Perhaps its failure provided valuable lessons for future ventures.

How often do you think about the long-term impact of your actions, like Astor might have?

Frequently – I try to make choices that benefit myself and others in the future.
Occasionally – I’m aware of it, but it’s not always at the forefront of my mind.
Rarely – I’m more focused on the present moment and immediate goals.
It’s something I’m working on – being more mindful of my legacy.

You are at a party and someone criticizes Astor’s wealth. What do you do?

Engage in conversation, offering a nuanced perspective on his life.
Listen politely, but avoid expressing my own opinion.
Steer the conversation towards a less controversial topic.
I might playfully defend Astor, highlighting his positive contributions.

How comfortable are you with the idea of profiting from real estate, knowing its complexities?

Very comfortable – it’s a proven way to build wealth.
Somewhat comfortable – as long as it’s done ethically.
Not very comfortable – I have ethical concerns about land ownership.
I need to learn more about it before forming a strong opinion.

You have 24 hours to spend as John Jacob Astor at the height of his wealth. What do you do?

Walk through my properties, imagining New York City’s future.
Host a lavish party at the Astor House, rubbing shoulders with elites.
Spend time in my library, surrounded by knowledge and culture.
I’d use my wealth to help those less fortunate in the city.

Which of these issues is most likely to be a struggle for you, as it might have been for Astor?

Balancing ambition with ethical considerations in business decisions.
Managing vast wealth and the responsibilities it brings.
Maintaining personal relationships amidst a demanding career.
I relate to his drive for success, but not at the cost of my values.

Which member of the Astor family are you most drawn to?

John Jacob Astor himself, for his ambition and vision.
Sarah Todd, his wife, for her strength and business acumen.
One of his descendants who used their wealth for philanthropy.
I’m more interested in John Jacob Astor as an individual.

New information about Astor’s philanthropic efforts is discovered. What is your first response?

It complicates his legacy, showing he wasn’t just driven by profit.
It’s nice to see a redeeming quality, but it doesn’t erase everything else.
I’m curious to learn more about the specific causes he supported.
It’s a reminder that people are complex and shouldn’t be easily categorized.

Someone asks, “What’s your take on Astor’s impact?” What’s the actual answer?

It’s a mixed bag – he drove progress but profited from an exploitative system.
He’s a product of his time, so judging him by today’s standards is tough.
He left an undeniable mark on America, both positive and negative.
His story is a reminder of the complexities of wealth and legacy.

What’s your go-to source for learning about historical figures like Astor?

Biographies that provide a well-researched and balanced perspective.
Historical fiction that brings their stories to life.
I enjoy documentaries that offer visual context and expert commentary.
I like to explore primary sources, like letters and journals, whenever possible.

What aspect of Astor’s era do you most want to explore further?

The fur trade’s impact on Native American communities.
The development of New York City into a global economic hub.
The social and cultural changes during America’s westward expansion.
The lives of ordinary people living during that time period.

What’s your favorite fact or story you learned about John Jacob Astor?

His rise from a butcher’s son to one of America’s wealthiest men.
His strategic purchase of land in Manhattan, which became incredibly valuable.
His establishment of the Astor Library, demonstrating his commitment to knowledge.
His complex and challenging venture to establish Astoria on the Pacific Coast.

What historical causes or figures are you most passionate about?

Social reformers who fought for justice and equality.
Entrepreneurs who shaped industries and drove innovation.
Artists and writers who challenged conventions and sparked cultural shifts.
I’m drawn to stories of resilience and triumph over adversity.

What is your absolute favorite thing about learning about the past, like Astor’s time?

Gaining a deeper understanding of how we arrived at the present moment.
Discovering the forgotten stories and perspectives of those who came before.
Connecting with the shared human experience across different times and cultures.
It’s fascinating to see how much has changed and also what remains the same.

How would your friends and family describe your approach to learning, especially about history?

As someone who loves to dive deep into a subject and uncover all the details.
As someone who enjoys a good story and connecting with the past through narratives.
As someone who’s always asking questions and seeking different perspectives.
I’m not sure they think much about my learning style, to be honest!

Tell us a little about your preferred method for engaging with historical information.

I prefer a balanced approach, combining factual details with engaging storytelling.
I’m drawn to visual mediums, like documentaries and historical maps.
I enjoy primary sources, as they offer direct insights into the past.
I like to discuss history with others and hear different interpretations.

If you could choose any artifact from Astor’s life to own, what would it be and why?

A map of New York City from his time, showing his landholdings.
A letter written in his own hand, revealing his thoughts and feelings.
A piece of furniture from the Astor House, representing his legacy.
His personal journal, offering a glimpse into his private reflections.

What’s the first thing that comes to mind when you hear the phrase “fur trade”?

Images of trappers in the wilderness and their interactions with Native Americans.
The economic significance of the fur trade in early America.
The complex ethical implications of the trade and its impact on indigenous communities.
Beautiful fur garments and the luxury they represented.

What historical event or movement do you think has affected you the most?

The Civil Rights Movement, for its impact on social justice and equality.
The Industrial Revolution, for its transformative effects on technology and society.
The rise and fall of empires throughout history, reminding us of the cyclical nature of power.
I’m constantly learning and being shaped by events from the past.

What’s your idea of a well-balanced approach to teaching and learning history?

Presenting multiple perspectives and encouraging critical thinking.
Connecting the past to the present and highlighting its relevance.
Making history engaging and accessible to diverse learners.
Incorporating primary sources and diverse voices to enrich understanding.

What is your strongest takeaway from learning about John Jacob Astor’s life and times?

The importance of hard work and determination in achieving success.
The complexities of ambition and the ethical dilemmas it can present.
The lasting impact individuals can have on the course of history.
The importance of understanding the past to navigate the present and future.

How prepared are you for a surprise quiz on 19th-century American entrepreneurs?

Bring it on! I’m a history buff and I love this kind of challenge.
I might know a thing or two, but I wouldn’t bet on acing it.
I’d probably need a lot of hints and reminders.
History isn’t really my strong suit, so I’ll take a pass on that one.

What happens if someone challenges your knowledge of Astor’s fur trading practices?

I’d engage in a respectful debate, citing sources and evidence.
I’d admit if I didn’t know something and be open to learning more.
I’d politely steer the conversation in a different direction.
I’m always up for a friendly history discussion, even if I don’t have all the answers.

What do you think you need to deepen your understanding of Astor’s impact on New York City?

A walking tour of his former properties and landmarks associated with him.
An in-depth read of a historical account focused specifically on that aspect.
To visit the locations and experience them firsthand.
To discuss his impact with historians or those with expertise in NYC history.

How often do you research historical figures or events out of personal interest?

All the time! I’m a history nerd and love to learn new things.
Every now and then, when something piques my curiosity.
Rarely – I prefer to focus on the present and the future.
It depends on the topic and how much time I have available.

How confident are you in your ability to identify primary sources from Astor’s time?

Very confident – I’m familiar with the types of documents from that era.
Moderately confident – I have a general understanding, but might need guidance.
Not very confident – I’d need help from an expert.
I’m willing to learn and improve my skills in this area.

How do you handle conflicting information when researching a historical figure like Astor?

I compare sources, considering their biases and perspectives.
I try to find a neutral account that presents a balanced view.
I focus on the facts that are most widely accepted by historians.
It can be frustrating, but it highlights the complexities of history.

Do you have a “go-to” resource for historical information, like a specific website or book series?

Yes, I rely on [Name of resource] for accurate and engaging history content.
I have a few trusted sources that I turn to depending on the topic.
I usually just start with a general internet search and go from there.
I’m always open to recommendations for new and reliable history resources.

How well do you think you adhere to the idea of viewing history objectively, without imposing modern values?

I’m aware of the dangers of presentism and try to avoid it.
It’s a constant challenge, but I strive for a balanced perspective.
I acknowledge my own biases and how they shape my understanding of the past.
It’s impossible to be completely objective, but we should strive for fairness.

Which of the following is most accurate when it comes to your understanding of the fur trade’s impact?

I recognize its complexity, acknowledging both economic benefits and exploitation.
I tend to focus on its negative aspects, particularly its impact on indigenous peoples.
I’m more interested in its economic significance and how it shaped global trade.
I need to learn more to form a well-informed opinion on the matter.

To what degree do you experience uncertainty or discomfort when encountering morally ambiguous figures from history?

I’m comfortable with nuance and recognize that no one is purely good or bad.
It can be challenging, but I try to understand their actions within their context.
I prefer to focus on the positive aspects of history and celebrate progress.
It depends on the specific actions and their impact on others.

Which of these best describes your current understanding of Astor’s motivations and values?

I believe he was a complex figure driven by both ambition and a desire to leave a legacy.
I see him as a product of his time, primarily motivated by profit within the existing system.
I need more information to form a concrete opinion on his character.
I’m interested in exploring the different interpretations of his life and motivations.

What is your current biggest challenge when attempting to reconcile Astor’s accomplishments with his participation in a system that exploited Native Americans?

Balancing his economic contributions with the ethical implications of his actions.
Separating the man from the historical context and prevailing attitudes of his time.
Understanding the perspectives of those impacted by the fur trade.
It’s a reminder that history is full of complexities and contradictions.

What’s the first thing that comes to mind when you think about the challenges faced by early American entrepreneurs?

The risks associated with westward expansion and navigating uncharted territories.
The competition from established European powers in various industries.
The lack of infrastructure and support systems that exist today.
The constant need to adapt and innovate to thrive in a rapidly changing world.

How do you handle the realization that historical figures we admire often have flaws and make mistakes?

It humanizes them and makes their stories more relatable.
It’s a reminder that no one is perfect and we all have the capacity for both good and bad.
It doesn’t diminish their accomplishments, but adds complexity to their legacies.
It encourages me to learn from their mistakes and strive to be a better person.

How would you describe your relationship to learning about history?

I have a passion for history and find it endlessly fascinating.
I appreciate history and recognize its importance, but it’s not my main focus.
I’m still developing my interest in history and finding my own way to connect with it.
I respect history, but I’m more interested in current events and the future.

Are you stuck in a cycle of relying on the same historical resources, or are you open to exploring new perspectives?

I’m always seeking out new voices and interpretations of history.
I have my favorites, but I try to branch out and challenge my own biases.
I’m open to recommendations, but I tend to stick with what I know.
I’m still learning and figuring out what resonates with me.

What would you say are your top struggles right now when it comes to forming an educated opinion on complex historical figures like Astor?

Avoiding presentism and judging past actions through a modern lens.
Accessing and understanding primary sources and their nuances.
Reconciling conflicting information and perspectives from different historians.
I’m getting better at navigating these challenges, but it’s an ongoing process.

What is your “history learning” goal? To become an expert on a specific period, or to cultivate a broader understanding of the past?

I’m aiming for expertise in [Specific period/topic], delving into its intricacies.
I prefer a broader approach, understanding the overarching narratives of history.
I want to be able to hold my own in conversations and appreciate different perspectives.
My goal is to become a more informed and engaged citizen through historical knowledge.

What do you think is missing in your quest to become more knowledgeable about history?

More time to dedicate to reading and research.
Access to primary sources and expert interpretations.
Opportunities for discussion and debate with other history enthusiasts.
I’m working on building a more structured approach to my learning.

What is your current level of expertise when it comes to understanding the economic landscape of 19th century America?

I have a strong foundation and can discuss key concepts and figures.
I’m still learning, but I grasp the basics and key events.
I’m relatively unfamiliar with this area, but I’m interested in learning more.
Economics isn’t my forte, but I appreciate its role in shaping history.

Imagine you’ve been transported back to 19th century New York. How do you respond to the sights, sounds, and social dynamics?

I’m overwhelmed but excited, eager to soak up every detail of this bygone era.
I’m observant, taking note of the social dynamics and comparing them to the present.
I’m uncomfortable with the lack of modern conveniences and social progress.
I’m eager to learn from the past and gain a deeper understanding of history.

What word best describes how you feel when learning about the past: curious, inspired, overwhelmed, or something else?

Definitely curious – I’m always eager to uncover more about history’s mysteries.
Inspired by the resilience and ingenuity of people from past generations.
A bit overwhelmed by the sheer vastness and complexity of it all.
I feel a sense of connection to the past and those who came before us.

Which of the following do you notice yourself worrying about on a day-to-day basis: the ethical implications of past events, the accuracy of historical accounts, or the relevance of history to the present day?

I often ponder how past injustices continue to shape our world today.
I’m concerned about bias in history and strive to find diverse perspectives.
I believe understanding the past is crucial for making informed decisions in the present.
I try to stay present-focused, but I acknowledge the importance of learning from the past.

How informed and engaged do you feel in your current understanding of John Jacob Astor?

I feel well-informed and capable of discussing his life and legacy in a nuanced way.
I’m still learning, but I feel more engaged and curious than I did before.
I have a basic understanding, but I recognize there’s much more to explore.
I’m just scratching the surface, but I’m open to diving deeper into his story.

How well do you think you balance acknowledging Astor’s business acumen with recognizing the exploitative systems he participated in?

It’s a delicate balance, but I strive to acknowledge both aspects without condoning harmful practices.
I lean towards emphasizing the negative consequences of his actions, even while recognizing his business skills.
I try to view him as a product of his time, while also acknowledging the lasting harm caused by those systems.
It’s a complex issue and I’m still working on forming a fully realized opinion.

I believe that John Jacob Astor’s legacy should be understood in the context of both his accomplishments and the ethical complexities of his time.

I completely agree.
I somewhat agree.
I disagree.
I’m not sure.

I’m afraid of misinterpreting or misrepresenting history due to my own biases and limited knowledge.

It’s a valid concern, and we should all strive for accuracy and fairness in our interpretations.
It’s important to acknowledge our limitations and be open to learning from others.
We should focus on sharing what we know and being open to correction when necessary.
History is constantly being re-evaluated, and it’s okay to make mistakes as long as we learn from them.

Which of the following is most likely to frustrate you when learning about history: encountering biased accounts, struggling to connect with the past, or feeling overwhelmed by the sheer volume of information?

I find biased or one-sided accounts incredibly frustrating, as they obscure the truth.
I sometimes struggle to relate to people from the past, which makes it harder to engage with their stories.
The sheer volume of information can be overwhelming, making it hard to know where to focus.
I enjoy the challenge of grappling with complex historical narratives.

What is the trickiest part about forming an opinion about a historical figure like John Jacob Astor?

Balancing his achievements with the ethical considerations of his business practices.
Separating the man from his time period and avoiding judging him by modern standards.
Navigating the often-conflicting accounts and interpretations of his life and actions.
All of the above.

Do you find yourself more drawn to Astor’s ambition and drive, or are you more troubled by the exploitative nature of the fur trade?

I admire his entrepreneurial spirit and vision, but I can’t overlook the harm inflicted on others.
I’m primarily focused on the negative consequences of his actions and the fur trade’s legacy.
I’m trying to hold both perspectives simultaneously and grapple with their complexities.
I’m more interested in understanding the historical context than making moral judgments.

Do you have a system in place for keeping track of the historical information you consume, such as a note-taking method or a digital tool?

Yes, I use [Describe your system] to organize my thoughts and findings.
I’m more of a casual learner, but I sometimes jot down notes or bookmark interesting resources.
I’m looking for a better system, as I often forget details or lose track of sources.
I’m open to suggestions for effective ways to organize historical information.

How do you determine your historical understanding’s depth each time you finish a book or documentary?

I reflect on key takeaways, consider unanswered questions, and seek additional resources to fill gaps.
I gauge my understanding by how easily I can discuss the topic and answer questions about it.
I rely on my own judgment and intuition to assess how much I’ve learned.
I often test my knowledge with quizzes or by discussing the topic with others.

Learn more