Narrative Summary of Contributions to the History of Psychology -- 1916-1921

Overview:

In this article, I trace the history of psychology during the period from 1916 to 1921. This was a time of significant upheaval, marked by the outbreak and aftermath of World War I. I discuss how the war mobilized psychology for military purposes, leading to a surge in interest in psychotechnology and “applied psychology.” I explore the debate surrounding introspection and behaviorism, as well as the continuing legacy of the German tradition in psychology. Finally, I examine the major historical and biographical works that appeared during this period.

Main Parts:

Part 1: The Impact of World War I: The article first examines the impact of World War I on psychology, detailing the mobilization of psychologists for military purposes. It highlights the significant contributions of psychologists in areas like aviation, intelligence, personnel selection, and the treatment of “war psychoses.”
Part 2: The Rise of Psychotechnology: The article then explores the emergence of psychotechnology as a significant field within psychology, highlighting the increased interest in applying psychological principles to real-world problems. It examines how this shift in focus impacted the development of the discipline.
Part 3: The Introspection vs. Behaviorism Debate: The article delves into the ongoing debate between introspection and behaviorism. It discusses the influence of Watson’s emphasis on objective methods and the continued support for introspection, particularly within the American Psychological Association.
Part 4: The German Tradition in Psychology: The article explores the enduring legacy of the German tradition in psychology. It analyzes the ongoing debate about the place of the German tradition in American psychology and the potential influence of biological perspectives on the discipline.
Part 5: Historical and Biographical Works: The article concludes with a review of significant historical and biographical works published during this period. It discusses general histories of psychology, such as Brett’s “History of Psychology,” and special historical studies focusing on topics like the psychology of emotions, the early development of physiological optics, and the lives of influential figures like Wundt and Pierce.

View on Life:

Behaviorism: This perspective emphasizes observable behaviors and the role of environmental factors in shaping behavior. Behaviorists believe that mental states are not directly observable and therefore cannot be scientifically studied. This view challenges the traditional focus on introspection and encourages a more practical approach to psychology.
Introspection: This perspective advocates for the use of introspection, or the examination of one’s own mental processes, as a valid and valuable method of psychological inquiry. Proponents of introspection argue that it provides essential insights into the nature of consciousness and the workings of the mind.
The German Tradition: This perspective emphasizes the importance of rigorous scientific methods and the role of philosophical inquiry in psychology. It values the contributions of German philosophers and psychologists like Wundt, and sees psychology as a discipline that draws on a diverse range of intellectual influences.

Scenarios:

World War I: This scenario explores the impact of the war on the development of psychology. It highlights how the war’s demands led to the mobilization of psychologists and the rapid development of applied psychological techniques.
The Rise of Psychotechnology: This scenario examines the increasing interest in applying psychological principles to real-world problems, particularly in areas like industry, education, and law. It discusses the impact of this shift on the discipline’s focus and methodology.
The Introspection vs. Behaviorism Debate: This scenario explores the debate surrounding the role of introspection in psychology. It presents the contrasting views of behaviorism, which emphasizes objectivity, and those who continue to value introspection as a valid research method.

Challenges:

The war’s influence: The war presented significant challenges to psychologists, who were forced to adapt to the demands of military service and to develop new methods for addressing practical problems.
The tension between theoretical and applied psychology: The growing emphasis on applied psychology led to debates about the discipline’s focus and direction. Some psychologists argued that this shift away from theoretical research was detrimental to the field’s development.
The need for a comprehensive history of psychology: The article notes the absence of a comprehensive history of psychology, highlighting the need for a more detailed account of the discipline’s development beyond the early periods.

Conflict:

The conflict between introspection and behaviorism: This conflict centers on the debate about the appropriate methodology for psychological inquiry. Behaviorists advocate for objective methods that focus on observable behaviors, while proponents of introspection argue for the value of subjective experience in understanding the mind.

Plot:

The narrative arc of this text: The article begins by exploring the impact of World War I on psychology. It then traces the subsequent development of psychotechnology and the debate between introspection and behaviorism. Finally, it concludes with a review of significant historical and biographical works that reflect the trends in psychology during this period.

Point of View:

The author’s perspective: The article is written from the perspective of a historian of psychology. The author emphasizes the impact of historical events, the development of different schools of thought, and the ongoing debate about the discipline’s direction.

How It’s Written:

Tone and style: The text is written in a formal, academic tone. It uses a clear and concise style, providing a comprehensive overview of the major developments in psychology during the period in question.
Example: “In spite of the heroic times through which the science has been passing, there are, at the present moment, no indubitable signs of a material or permanent change in its general character.”

Tone:

Objective: The article strives for objectivity in its presentation of different perspectives and debates. It avoids taking a strong stance on any particular view and instead aims to present a balanced overview of the major trends in psychology during this period.

Life Choices:

The choice to focus on applied psychology: The war’s influence led to an increased interest in applied psychology, raising questions about the appropriate balance between theoretical and practical research.

Lessons:

The importance of adaptation: The war demonstrated the importance of adaptability in psychology, as practitioners were forced to develop new methods to meet the demands of military service.
The impact of historical events on scientific development: The article highlights how major events like World War I can significantly shape the development of scientific disciplines.

Characters:

Wilhelm Wundt: A German psychologist who established the first experimental psychology laboratory. He is considered one of the founders of modern psychology.
John B. Watson: An American psychologist who is credited with founding behaviorism. He argued that psychology should focus on observable behaviors and environmental influences rather than mental states.
Edward B. Titchener: An American psychologist who advocated for the use of introspection as a method of psychological inquiry. He was a leading figure in the structuralist school of psychology.
James McKeen Cattell: An American psychologist who made significant contributions to the development of psychological testing and the study of individual differences.

Themes:

The role of history in shaping psychology: The article emphasizes the influence of historical events, such as the war, on the development of the discipline.
The tension between theory and practice: The article explores the ongoing debate about the appropriate balance between theoretical and applied research in psychology.
The search for a unified approach to psychology: The article discusses the challenges of finding a single, unifying approach to psychology, as evidenced by the contrasting perspectives of behaviorism and introspection.

Principles:

Empiricism: The article highlights the importance of empirical methods in psychology, particularly the emphasis on observation and experimentation.
Objectivity: The article discusses the ongoing debate about the role of objectivity in psychological inquiry. Behaviorists emphasize objectivity, while proponents of introspection argue for the importance of subjective experience.

Intentions:

Authors: The authors of the cited works sought to advance the understanding of psychology through historical research, biographical analysis, and the exploration of different theoretical perspectives.
Reader: A reader of this text would gain a better understanding of the major developments in psychology during the period from 1916-1921, including the impact of World War I, the rise of psychotechnology, and the ongoing debate between introspection and behaviorism.

Unique Vocabulary:

Psychotechnology: The application of psychological principles to practical problems in fields like industry, education, and law.
War psychoses: Mental disorders that developed as a result of the trauma and stress of war.
Introspection: The examination of one’s own mental processes.
Behaviorism: A school of psychology that emphasizes observable behaviors and environmental influences.
German tradition: The influence of German philosophy and psychology on the development of the discipline.

Anecdotes:

The story of Gall and phrenology: The article discusses Bentley’s study of the psychological antecedents of phrenology, emphasizing that Gall’s work was significant not only for its theories but also for its attempt to integrate psychological and anatomical knowledge.
Theophrastus and early Greek physiological psychology: Stratton’s study of Theophrastus’ writings highlights the importance of this figure as a source of knowledge about early Greek physiological psychology.

Ideas:

The idea that psychology should be more practical: The article explores the growing emphasis on applied psychology and the debate about the discipline’s role in addressing real-world problems.
The idea that introspection is a valid method of inquiry: The article discusses the arguments in favor of introspection, particularly its role in understanding subjective experience.

Facts and Findings:

The growth of psychotechnology: The article highlights the rapid development of psychotechnology during this period, particularly in response to the demands of World War I.
The establishment of new psychological laboratories: The article discusses the establishment of new laboratories, psychological institutes, and departments, reflecting the discipline’s growing academic status.
The necrology of the period: The article lists the names of influential figures in psychology who died during this period, highlighting the passing of a generation of psychologists and the emergence of a new generation.

Statistics:

The article reports that more than a fourth of the members of the American Psychological Association entered military service during World War I.
The article notes the establishment of twenty-two new laboratories in the United States during the decade leading up to 1919.

Points of View:

The article presents the contrasting views of introspection and behaviorism, reflecting the debate about the appropriate methodology for psychological inquiry.
The article also discusses the ongoing debate about the place of the German tradition in American psychology.

Perspective:

The article offers a historical perspective on the development of psychology during the period from 1916-1921, emphasizing the impact of events like World War I and the emergence of new schools of thought.
The article also offers a critical perspective on the discipline, highlighting the challenges of finding a unified approach to psychology and the need for a more comprehensive history of the field.

Learn more