What is the name of the law that suggests simpler explanations are preferred over more complex ones?
- Law of Complexity
- Law of Parsimony
- Law of Design
- Law of Adaptation
Correct Answer: Law of Parsimony
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes emphasizes the “law of parsimony,” also known as Occam’s razor, in his argument. He suggests that natural selection, being a simpler explanation for the diversity of life, is more likely to be true than the theory of separate creation.
Which of these is NOT a type of evidence for evolution that Romanes cites in his essay?
- The study of fossils
- The study of how organisms develop
- The study of how organisms are classified
- The study of the speed of light
Correct Answer: The study of the speed of light
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes focuses on biological evidence to support evolution, including fossil records (paleontology), developmental patterns (embryology), and classification systems. The study of the speed of light is a physics concept and not relevant to biological evolution.
What does the presence of rudimentary organs suggest about evolution?
- Organisms are perfectly designed.
- Organisms are evolving towards a more complex state.
- Organisms have descended from ancestors with functional versions of those organs.
- Organisms are constantly adapting to new environments.
Correct Answer: Organisms have descended from ancestors with functional versions of those organs.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes highlights the presence of rudimentary organs, like the human tailbone, as evidence for evolution. These structures are remnants of organs that were functional in ancestors, suggesting descent with modification.
How does the geographical distribution of species support the theory of evolution?
- Species are evenly distributed across the globe.
- Species found on isolated islands often differ from those on continents.
- Species are more similar in environments with similar climates.
- Species have migrated to every corner of the Earth.
Correct Answer: Species found on isolated islands often differ from those on continents.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes argues that the unique species found on isolated islands, like the Galapagos Islands, are evidence for evolution. These species have evolved differently due to isolation and adaptation to their specific environments.
Which of these is NOT an example of an adaptation that Romanes uses to support the idea of evolution?
- The whale’s flippers
- The bat’s wings
- The snake’s lack of limbs
- The giraffe’s long neck
Correct Answer: The giraffe’s long neck
Correct Answer Explanation: While the giraffe’s long neck is a classic example of adaptation, Romanes doesn’t specifically cite it in his essay. He focuses on examples like whales, bats, and snakes to illustrate how features have evolved over time.
What does the evolutionary history of the horse, as described by Romanes, reveal?
- Horses have always had a single toe.
- Horses have evolved from a five-toed ancestor.
- Horses are not closely related to other mammals.
- Horses have remained unchanged for millions of years.
Correct Answer: Horses have evolved from a five-toed ancestor.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes mentions the horse’s evolution from a five-toed ancestor, highlighting the presence of splint bones in the modern horse’s leg as evidence of this evolutionary journey.
What aspect of human embryology does Romanes cite as evidence for our evolutionary relationship with other animals?
- Human embryos develop with gills.
- Human embryos develop with a tail.
- Human embryos develop with fur.
- All of the above
Correct Answer: All of the above
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes emphasizes that human embryos exhibit characteristics found in lower vertebrates, such as gill slits, a tail, and a thick coat of hair, suggesting a shared evolutionary history.
What is the main point that Romanes makes regarding the human eye?
- The human eye is a perfect example of design.
- The human eye has evolved through a series of small changes.
- The human eye is a testament to the power of intelligent design.
- The human eye is too complex to have evolved naturally.
Correct Answer: The human eye has evolved through a series of small changes.
Correct Answer Explanation: Despite its complexity, Romanes points out that the human eye is not optically perfect, suggesting that it evolved through gradual changes rather than being perfectly designed.
According to Romanes, what makes the theory of evolution more plausible than the theory of separate creation?
- The theory of evolution is supported by a greater body of evidence.
- The theory of evolution is more aesthetically pleasing.
- The theory of evolution is more consistent with religious beliefs.
- The theory of evolution is simpler and more parsimonious.
Correct Answer: The theory of evolution is simpler and more parsimonious.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes emphasizes the law of parsimony, suggesting that the simplicity of natural selection makes it a more likely explanation for the diversity of life than the theory of separate creation.
What is the significance of the geological record in supporting the theory of evolution?
- It shows that species have remained unchanged over time.
- It shows that fossils are found in random order.
- It shows a gradual progression of complexity in life forms.
- It shows that the Earth is very young.
Correct Answer: It shows a gradual progression of complexity in life forms.
Correct Answer Explanation: The geological record, according to Romanes, shows a pattern of increasing complexity in fossils, from simple organisms in early strata to more complex ones in later strata, supporting the theory of evolution.
How does Romanes counter the emotional argument that evolution is “degrading” to humans?
- He argues that humans are not descended from apes.
- He argues that evolution is a process of progress, not degradation.
- He argues that humans are fundamentally different from other animals.
- He argues that scientific progress often challenges established notions of dignity.
Correct Answer: He argues that scientific progress often challenges established notions of dignity.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes addresses the emotional resistance to evolution by arguing that scientific progress often challenges established beliefs about human dignity, and that the similarities between humans and apes point towards a shared ancestry rather than separate creation.
Why does Romanes believe that the theory of evolution is more probable than the theory of separate creation?
- The theory of evolution is based on faith.
- The theory of evolution is supported by a greater body of evidence.
- The theory of evolution is simpler and more parsimonious.
- All of the above
Correct Answer: The theory of evolution is supported by a greater body of evidence.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes’s main argument is that the weight of evidence from various fields of science overwhelmingly supports the theory of evolution. He presents a detailed analysis of the evidence to show its consistency and the relative lack of evidence for separate creation.
What is the key takeaway from Romanes’s essay “The Scientific Evidences of Organic Evolution”?
- Evolution is a proven fact.
- Evolution is a theory that is supported by a vast body of evidence.
- Evolution is a process that is only partially understood.
- Evolution is a threat to religious beliefs.
Correct Answer: Evolution is a theory that is supported by a vast body of evidence.
Correct Answer Explanation: While acknowledging that evolution is a theory and not a proven fact, Romanes argues that the weight of evidence from various fields of science makes the theory of evolution highly probable.
What does Romanes mean when he discusses the “struggle for existence”?
- A competition for resources among organisms.
- A battle between humans and nature.
- A desire to reach a higher state of being.
- A conflict between different species.
Correct Answer: A competition for resources among organisms.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes uses the term “struggle for existence” to describe the competition for limited resources among organisms. This struggle leads to natural selection, where individuals with advantageous traits are more likely to survive and reproduce.
How does Romanes explain the presence of instincts in animals?
- Instincts are predetermined behaviors.
- Instincts are learned through experience.
- Instincts are a result of divine intervention.
- Instincts are inherited from ancestors.
Correct Answer: Instincts are inherited from ancestors.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes argues that instincts are complex adaptations that are inherited from ancestors, not learned or divinely given. He suggests that these inherited traits reflect the evolutionary history of organisms.
According to Romanes, why are some species absent from oceanic islands?
- They are not designed to live there.
- They lack the ability to travel across oceans.
- They are hunted by predators on the islands.
- They are unable to adapt to the new environment.
Correct Answer: They lack the ability to travel across oceans.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes notes the absence of certain species, like frogs and toads, on oceanic islands because they lack the ability to survive saltwater travel. This reinforces the importance of geographical barriers in shaping species distribution.
What is Romanes’s argument regarding the human brain and the brains of other apes?
- They are completely different.
- They are remarkably similar.
- They are both designed by God.
- They are both evolving towards perfection.
Correct Answer: They are remarkably similar.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes emphasizes the striking similarities between the human brain and the brains of higher apes, suggesting a shared evolutionary history and descent from a common ancestor.
Which of these is NOT a factor that contributes to the evolution of species?
- Mutation
- Natural Selection
- Artificial Selection
- Intelligent Design
Correct Answer: Intelligent Design
Correct Answer Explanation: While Romanes addresses arguments for intelligent design, his central focus is on natural selection and other factors like mutation and artificial selection that contribute to the evolution of species. Intelligent design, as a concept, is not scientifically supported as a mechanism for evolution.
What is the relationship between variation and natural selection?
- Variation is necessary for natural selection to occur.
- Natural selection creates variation within a population.
- Variation and natural selection are independent of each other.
- Variation is the result of natural selection.
Correct Answer: Variation is necessary for natural selection to occur.
Correct Answer Explanation: Natural selection operates on existing variation within a population. Without variation, there would be no differences among individuals for natural selection to act upon, leading to no evolutionary change.
What does Romanes mean by the term “survival of the fittest”?
- Only the strongest individuals will survive.
- Individuals best suited to their environment will survive and reproduce.
- Survival is a random process.
- Survival is a struggle between individuals and nature.
Correct Answer: Individuals best suited to their environment will survive and reproduce.
Correct Answer Explanation: “Survival of the fittest,” coined by Herbert Spencer, describes the process of natural selection where individuals with advantageous traits are more likely to survive and reproduce, passing those traits on to their offspring.
Which of these examples does Romanes use to illustrate the importance of isolation in evolution?
- The Galapagos Islands
- The Malay Archipelago
- The West Indian Islands
- All of the above
Correct Answer: All of the above
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes uses these island systems as examples of how isolation has led to the evolution of unique species. The geographical barriers, like oceans, have influenced the evolutionary pathways of organisms on these islands.
What is the main takeaway from the scientific evidence presented in Romanes’s essay?
- The theory of evolution is a highly probable explanation for the diversity of life.
- The theory of separate creation is the most likely explanation for the diversity of life.
- Evolution is a slow and gradual process.
- Evolution is a process that can be directly observed.
Correct Answer: The theory of evolution is a highly probable explanation for the diversity of life.
Correct Answer Explanation: The essay presents a strong argument for the theory of evolution, drawing on evidence from various fields of science to demonstrate its consistency and the relative lack of support for the theory of separate creation.
According to Romanes, what is the significance of the “deep water channel” separating islands in the Malay Archipelago?
- It demonstrates the influence of geographical barriers on evolution.
- It indicates that the islands were once connected.
- It explains why the islands have similar species.
- It proves that the Earth is very old.
Correct Answer: It demonstrates the influence of geographical barriers on evolution.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes cites the deep water channel as an example of how geographical barriers, like the depth of the sea, can lead to the evolution of distinct species on either side of the barrier.
Which of these is an argument that Romanes presents against the theory of intelligent design?
- The existence of imperfections in organisms.
- The complexity of the human eye.
- The vast diversity of life on Earth.
- All of the above
Correct Answer: All of the above
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes argues against intelligent design by pointing out the imperfections in organisms, the complexity of structures like the human eye, and the immense diversity of life on Earth, suggesting that these features are more likely to be products of natural processes rather than perfect design.
What does Romanes believe is the most powerful evidence for evolution?
- The fossil record
- The geographical distribution of species
- The embryological development of organisms
- The similarity between human and ape brains
Correct Answer: The fossil record
Correct Answer Explanation: While Romanes presents a range of evidence, he highlights the fossil record as particularly strong evidence for evolution, showing a pattern of increasing complexity in life forms over geological time.
How does Romanes explain the presence of adaptations that seem perplexing in certain environments?
- These adaptations are a result of divine intervention.
- These adaptations are evidence of past environmental conditions.
- These adaptations are a result of random chance.
- These adaptations are a product of intelligent design.
Correct Answer: These adaptations are evidence of past environmental conditions.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes suggests that adaptations, like seed dispersal hooks in plants found on islands without mammals, may reflect past environmental conditions, indicating that organisms have evolved in response to changing environments.
According to Romanes, what is the primary mechanism that drives the process of evolution?
- Artificial Selection
- Natural Selection
- Intelligent Design
- Mutation
Correct Answer: Natural Selection
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes presents natural selection as the primary driving force of evolution, emphasizing how organisms best suited to their environment tend to survive and reproduce more successfully, passing those traits to their offspring.
What is the key difference between natural selection and artificial selection?
- Natural selection is driven by human intervention, while artificial selection is driven by environmental factors.
- Natural selection is driven by environmental factors, while artificial selection is driven by human intervention.
- Natural selection is a random process, while artificial selection is a planned process.
- Natural selection operates on individual organisms, while artificial selection operates on entire populations.
Correct Answer: Natural selection is driven by environmental factors, while artificial selection is driven by human intervention.
Correct Answer Explanation: Natural selection is a natural process where the environment selects for organisms with traits that increase their survival and reproduction, while artificial selection is a process where humans intentionally select for specific traits.
According to Romanes, what is the most compelling argument against the idea of separate creation?
- The lack of evidence for separate creation.
- The complexity of organisms.
- The diversity of life on Earth.
- The simplicity of natural selection.
Correct Answer: The simplicity of natural selection.
Correct Answer Explanation: While Romanes presents a wide range of evidence, he highlights the simplicity of natural selection as a compelling argument against separate creation. He suggests that natural selection, being a simpler and more parsimonious explanation, is more likely to be true.
What is the significance of Romanes’s essay in the history of evolutionary thought?
- It provided the first scientific evidence for evolution.
- It presented a concise and accessible argument for Darwin’s theory.
- It refuted all arguments against evolution.
- It sparked widespread acceptance of evolution.
Correct Answer: It presented a concise and accessible argument for Darwin’s theory.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes’s essay was important for its clear and concise presentation of the scientific evidence supporting Darwin’s theory of evolution. It helped to popularize and strengthen the argument for evolution at a time when it was still facing significant resistance.
How does Romanes address the concern that evolution is a process of “degradation” for humans?
- He argues that humans are at the pinnacle of evolution.
- He argues that evolution is a process of progress, not degradation.
- He argues that humans are fundamentally different from other animals.
- He argues that scientific progress often challenges established notions of dignity.
Correct Answer: He argues that scientific progress often challenges established notions of dignity.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes acknowledges that the idea of humans being related to other animals can be challenging, but he emphasizes that scientific progress often challenges pre-existing beliefs about human dignity, and that the similarities between humans and apes point towards shared ancestry.
According to Romanes, what is the primary source of variation within a population?
- Mutation
- Natural Selection
- Artificial Selection
- Intelligent Design
Correct Answer: Mutation
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes acknowledges that mutation is the primary source of variation within a population, providing the raw material upon which natural selection can act.
What is Romanes’s perspective on the role of reason in understanding the natural world?
- Reason is essential for understanding the complexities of nature.
- Reason can be used to challenge established beliefs about nature.
- Reason is a powerful tool for uncovering the truth about nature.
- All of the above
Correct Answer: All of the above
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes emphasizes the importance of reason in understanding the natural world, arguing that it can challenge pre-existing beliefs, uncover new truths, and help us make sense of the complexities of life.
How does Romanes’s essay contribute to the ongoing debate about evolution and intelligent design?
- It provides a definitive answer to the debate.
- It presents a compelling case for the theory of evolution.
- It demonstrates the scientific superiority of intelligent design.
- It highlights the limitations of science in understanding the natural world.
Correct Answer: It presents a compelling case for the theory of evolution.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes’s essay presents a compelling argument for Darwin’s theory of evolution, highlighting the scientific evidence and addressing common objections, contributing to the ongoing debate about evolution and intelligent design.
What is the main point that Romanes seeks to convey in his essay?
- Evolution is a proven fact.
- Evolution is a theory that is supported by a vast body of evidence.
- Evolution is a process that is only partially understood.
- Evolution is a threat to religious beliefs.
Correct Answer: Evolution is a theory that is supported by a vast body of evidence.
Correct Answer Explanation: While acknowledging that evolution is a theory and not a proven fact, Romanes argues that the weight of evidence from various fields of science makes the theory of evolution highly probable.
What role does the concept of “descent with modification” play in Romanes’s argument?
- It explains how species are perfectly designed.
- It explains how species have evolved from common ancestors.
- It explains how species have remained unchanged over time.
- It explains how species are created independently of each other.
Correct Answer: It explains how species have evolved from common ancestors.
Correct Answer Explanation: “Descent with modification,” a key concept in Darwin’s theory, is central to Romanes’s argument. He uses this concept to explain the similarities and differences among species, suggesting that they have evolved from common ancestors through a process of gradual change.
How does Romanes address the argument that evolution contradicts religious beliefs?
- He argues that evolution is incompatible with religion.
- He argues that religion and science are separate domains.
- He argues that evolution is a divinely guided process.
- He argues that religious beliefs should be based on scientific evidence.
Correct Answer: He argues that religion and science are separate domains.
Correct Answer Explanation: While acknowledging that some people may have religious objections to evolution, Romanes emphasizes that science and religion are separate domains, and that the scientific evidence for evolution should be considered independently of religious beliefs.
What is the main takeaway from Romanes’s discussion of the “imperfections” in organisms?
- Organisms are not perfectly designed.
- Organisms are constantly evolving towards perfection.
- Organisms are evidence of intelligent design.
- Organisms are created independently of each other.
Correct Answer: Organisms are not perfectly designed.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes points out the imperfections in organisms, like the human eye’s imperfect optical design, as evidence against the idea of perfect design. He argues that these imperfections are consistent with the idea of evolution through natural processes.
How does Romanes’s essay connect to broader issues of human nature and our place in the natural world?
- It suggests that humans are the pinnacle of creation.
- It suggests that humans are separate from the natural world.
- It suggests that humans have a special role to play in the natural world.
- It suggests that humans are part of a continuous evolutionary process.
Correct Answer: It suggests that humans are part of a continuous evolutionary process.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes’s essay connects to broader issues of human nature by demonstrating that humans are part of a continuous evolutionary process, connected to other life forms through a shared ancestry.
What is the most important message that Romanes seeks to convey about the scientific evidence for evolution?
- It is a proven fact.
- It is a controversial theory.
- It is a complex and nuanced topic.
- It is a compelling and convincing argument.
Correct Answer: It is a compelling and convincing argument.
Correct Answer Explanation: Romanes’s main goal is to present a compelling and convincing argument for the theory of evolution, using the available scientific evidence to persuade his readers of its validity.