The Discovery of America by the Northmen, 985-1015 Informative Summary

Overview:

This text delves into the historical accounts of the Northmen’s voyages to America, occurring around the year 1000, nearly a century before Christopher Columbus. The story unfolds through Icelandic sagas, ancient oral narratives that were eventually written down, offering a glimpse into the explorers’ journey across the Atlantic. The author, Edmund F. Slafter, meticulously examines the evidence, exploring the authenticity and limitations of the sagas, particularly when it comes to identifying specific locations.

While the sagas provide a general framework for understanding the Northmen’s discoveries, they lack precise details regarding their landing sites, making it challenging to pinpoint the exact location of Vineland. The text highlights the importance of careful historical analysis, emphasizing the need to distinguish fact from fiction and acknowledge the limitations of oral tradition. Despite the uncertainties, the text establishes the historical significance of the Northmen’s voyages, recognizing their contribution to the discovery of America.

Key Findings:

The Icelandic sagas, although written centuries later, provide evidence of the Northmen’s voyages to America.
The sagas describe the discovery of three distinct lands: Helluland (likely Newfoundland), Markland (possibly Nova Scotia), and Vineland (most likely New England).
The sagas lack detailed descriptions of the explorers’ landing sites, making it difficult to pinpoint their exact locations.
No archaeological evidence has been found that definitively confirms the Northmen’s presence in America.
Despite the challenges in verifying details, the general narrative of the sagas is widely accepted by historians.

Learning:

The Importance of Oral Tradition: The text showcases the challenges and limitations of oral tradition in preserving historical accuracy. The sagas, passed down through generations, underwent transformations and modifications, leaving room for ambiguity and uncertainty.
The Difficulty of Historical Reconstruction: The author demonstrates how difficult it can be to reconstruct historical events, particularly those from a period with limited written documentation. The sagas provide insights but lack the precision needed for absolute certainty.
The Significance of the Northmen’s Voyages: While the details of their explorations remain uncertain, the text underscores the historical significance of the Northmen’s voyages to America. Their discovery, predating Columbus, reveals the early connections between Europe and the New World.

Historical Context:

The text is set in the context of the Viking Age, a period marked by Scandinavian expansion and exploration. The colonization of Iceland and Greenland, driven by political tensions and a desire for greater freedom, provided a springboard for further voyages westward. The discovery of America, though not immediately recognized for its full implications, represents a significant moment in the history of transatlantic exploration.

Facts:

Harald Haarfager unified Norway: In the mid-9th century, Harald Haarfager, a powerful king, united the previously fragmented principalities of Norway under his rule.
Iceland was colonized by Norwegians: Around 874, Norwegians fleeing Harald Haarfager’s oppressive rule sought refuge in Iceland, establishing a colony that flourished over time.
Greenland was discovered by the Norse: Around the year 985, Greenland was discovered by the Norse and a colony was established, which endured for several centuries.
Bjarni discovered new lands: Around 985, Bjarni, a Norwegian merchant, while sailing from Iceland to Greenland, accidentally discovered new lands to the west of Greenland, described as low, forested, and different from Greenland.
Leif Eriksson led the first intentional expedition: Leif Eriksson, the son of Erik the Red, led the first intentional voyage to explore the lands discovered by Bjarni in the year 1000.
Leif Eriksson named the lands: Leif Eriksson named the first land Helluland (likely Newfoundland), the second Markland (possibly Nova Scotia), and the third Vineland (most likely New England).
Vineland was a fertile region: Vineland was described as a land with grapes, good timber, and mild climate.
Thorvald, Leif’s brother, explored further: Thorvald, Leif’s brother, led another expedition to Vineland in 1002, spending three winters there and exploring the region extensively.
Thorvald encountered native inhabitants: Thorvald’s expedition encountered native inhabitants, leading to a hostile conflict in which Thorvald was killed.
Thorstein’s expedition to retrieve Thorvald’s body failed: Thorstein, Leif’s brother, attempted to retrieve Thorvald’s body but failed to find Vineland and returned to Greenland.
Thorfinn Karlsefni led the largest expedition: Thorfinn Karlsefni, a wealthy Icelandic merchant, led the largest expedition to Vineland in 1007, with three ships and over 160 men.
Karlsefni’s expedition encountered hostility from natives: Karlsefni’s expedition faced significant hostility from native inhabitants, forcing them to abandon plans for a permanent settlement.
Freydis, Leif’s half-sister, led a voyage: Freydis, Leif’s half-sister, led her own voyage to Vineland in 1011, with the aim of establishing a colony.
Freydis was known for her ruthless character: Freydis is described as a bold and unscrupulous woman who betrayed her partners, leading to their deaths.
The sagas were written down centuries later: The sagas that recount the voyages to America were not written down until the 13th century, over two hundred years after the events.
The sagas were memorized and recited orally: Before being written, the sagas were memorized and recited orally by professional narrators known as sagamen.
The sagas contain no evidence of permanent settlements: The sagas offer no indication that the Northmen established permanent settlements or constructed substantial buildings in America.
The sagas offer only general descriptions of the locations: The sagas provide general descriptions of the lands discovered but lack specific details that would allow for definitive identification of the places explored.
The Dighton Rock inscriptions are not understood: The inscriptions on the Dighton Rock, previously attributed to the Northmen, remain uninterpreted and are now generally believed to be the work of Native Americans.
The “Skeleton in Armor” is not of Scandinavian origin: The “Skeleton in Armor,” found at Fall River, is not considered evidence of the Northmen’s presence in America, and is more likely the remains of a Native American.

Statistics:

31 principalities in Norway: Norway was divided into 31 separate principalities before Harald Haarfager unified the nation.
35 men on Leif Eriksson’s ship: Leif Eriksson’s initial expedition to Vineland involved a crew of 35 men.
160 men on Karlsefni’s expedition: The largest expedition, led by Thorfinn Karlsefni, consisted of 160 men across three ships.
3 winters spent by Thorvald’s expedition: Thorvald’s expedition spent three winters in Vineland, mainly relying on fish for sustenance.
25 men on Thorstein’s expedition: Thorstein, Leif’s brother, led an expedition with 25 chosen men to retrieve Thorvald’s body.
100 years before Columbus: The Northmen’s voyages to America predate Columbus’s discoveries by roughly 100 years.
150-300 years of oral tradition: The sagas existed only in oral tradition for a period of 150 to 300 years before being written down.

Terms:

Sagamen: Professional storytellers who memorized and recited oral narratives known as sagas.
Sagas: Ancient Icelandic oral narratives, later written down, that recount historical events, myths, and legends.
Vineland: The name given by Leif Eriksson to the land he discovered, which is believed to be somewhere on the coast of North America.
Helluland: A land discovered by the Northmen, likely Newfoundland.
Markland: Another land discovered by the Northmen, possibly Nova Scotia.
Sound: A narrow body of water connecting two larger bodies of water, often shallow.
Ness: A promontory or tongue of land extending into the sea.
Booths: Temporary shelters constructed of materials readily available in the surrounding environment.
Rune: An ancient Germanic alphabet used by the Northmen for writing and inscription.
Sciolists: Individuals who have a superficial knowledge of a subject but lack in-depth understanding.

Examples:

Bjarni’s accidental discovery: Bjarni’s voyage from Iceland to Greenland was blown off course, leading to the accidental discovery of new lands to the west.
Leif Eriksson’s exploration of Helluland: Leif Eriksson landed on the first land he discovered, describing it as flat and covered with flat stones and icy mountains in the distance.
Thorvald’s encounter with native inhabitants: Thorvald’s expedition encountered a large group of natives armed with missiles and using boats made from animal skin, leading to a violent clash.
Thorstein’s unsuccessful search for Vineland: Thorstein’s expedition, seeking Thorvald’s body, failed to locate Vineland and returned to Greenland without it.
Karlsefni’s attempt at permanent settlement: Karlsefni’s expedition, aiming to establish a colony in Vineland, encountered significant hostility from natives, leading them to abandon their plans.
Freydis’s ruthless betrayal: Freydis, Leif’s half-sister, betrayed her partners on her expedition, leading to their deaths, demonstrating her ruthlessness.
The stone structure in Newport, Rhode Island: The stone structure in Newport, previously attributed to the Northmen, is now understood to be of later origin and not a remnant of their presence.
The Dighton Rock inscriptions: The inscriptions on the Dighton Rock, once thought to be of Northmen origin, are now believed to be the work of Native Americans, with no clear interpretation.
The “Skeleton in Armor” at Fall River: The “Skeleton in Armor,” found at Fall River, is more likely the remains of a Native American and not a Scandinavian explorer.
The “Tenterden steeple” and the “Goodwin Sands”: The author uses the metaphor of the “Tenterden steeple” and the “Goodwin Sands” to illustrate how people often falsely connect unrelated events, highlighting the need for careful historical analysis.

Conclusion:

While the Northmen’s voyages to America have been a subject of historical debate, the text provides a compelling case for their existence. Based on the evidence presented in the Icelandic sagas, it is likely that they indeed made several voyages to the shores of North America, predating Columbus by nearly a century. However, the lack of precise details and the absence of tangible archaeological evidence make it difficult to confirm the exact locations of their landing sites and settlements. The text emphasizes the importance of critical historical analysis, acknowledging the limitations of oral tradition and the challenges of reconstructing historical events with incomplete information. Despite these uncertainties, the Northmen’s voyages remain a fascinating testament to early transatlantic exploration and their impact on the history of North America.

Learn more