The Ethics of Freedom: Notes Selected, Translated, and Arranged by His Pupil James Gibson Hume Quiz Questions and Answers

How do you feel about the idea of “Liberty of Indifference” – that we have free will even in the absence of any motive?

I find it liberating, a testament to our capacity for unconstrained choice.
It seems illogical. Choices stem from our values and desires, not from a void.
I’m unsure, it’s a complex concept that requires deeper thought.

What’s your favorite argument Professor Young uses to critique Utilitarianism?

His emphasis on disinterested action, proving that we seek more than just pleasure.
His analysis of moral causation, revealing the flaws in tying morality to outcomes.
His dismantling of the “strongest motive” theory, highlighting its vagueness.

What makes you nervous about the concept of moral causation, the idea that character determines actions?

It feels deterministic, like we lack agency in our own moral development.
It raises concerns about accountability, if our actions are predetermined by our nature.
It makes me question the possibility of growth and change if our actions are preordained.

What makes you most frustrated about the ongoing debate between free will and determinism?

The lack of a definitive answer, leaving us in a philosophical limbo.
The potential for both extremes to be paralyzing – absolute freedom or absolute predetermination.
The tendency for the debate to become abstract and disconnected from lived experience.

What are you most excited about when considering Professor Young’s emphasis on moral development?

The potential for growth, the idea that we can continually strive for a higher moral condition.
The empowering nature of taking responsibility for our moral progress, instead of being passive.
The hope it offers for a more just and compassionate world, as individuals refine their moral compass.

What do you dream about when it comes to applying the principles of The Ethics of Freedom to your own life?

Becoming a more discerning moral agent, making choices rooted in thoughtful reflection.
Finding fulfillment in pursuing knowledge and engaging in acts of disinterested kindness.
Cultivating a more profound understanding of myself and my place in the world.

What happened in the past when you first encountered a philosophical dilemma related to free will or ethics?

I felt a sense of curiosity and intrigue, eager to explore the complexities.
I experienced confusion and uncertainty, questioning my own beliefs and values.
I felt a sense of responsibility, realizing the weight of making choices aligned with my principles.

What comes to mind when you think about the role of conscience in moral decision-making?

A guiding voice, but one that requires careful consideration and potential refinement.
A source of both clarity and conflict, as internal values might clash with external pressures.
A reflection of our ongoing moral development, evolving as we learn and grow.

What’s your favorite takeaway from Professor Young’s critique of Kant’s “Categorical Imperative”?

The highlighting of Kant’s “purism” and “rigorism”, suggesting a lack of nuance in his approach.
The emphasis on finding satisfaction in fulfilling moral obligations, not just acting out of duty.
The questioning of whether a single, universal principle can adequately address the complexity of ethics.

When you were a kid, how did you approach questions about right and wrong, good and evil?

I relied on the guidance of authority figures, accepting their interpretations.
I explored different perspectives, engaging in debates and seeking my own understanding.
I acted intuitively, based on empathy and a sense of fairness.

You have a choice of reading a modern philosophical text or revisiting The Ethics of Freedom, which do you choose?

The modern text, eager to explore contemporary perspectives on these timeless issues.
The Ethics of Freedom, drawn back to Professor Young’s insightful analysis and historical context.
I’m torn, both options offer valuable insights and opportunities for reflection.

A specific ethical dilemma arises, requiring a difficult decision – do you prioritize your personal values or consider the greater good?

I prioritize my values, staying true to my moral compass even if it leads to personal cost.
I prioritize the greater good, even if it requires compromising my own preferences in the process.
I try to find a balance, seeking a solution that honors both my values and the well-being of others.

What keeps you up at night about the current state of ethics and morality in the world?

The erosion of empathy, the increasing polarization and lack of understanding between different groups.
The influence of self-interest and the pursuit of power, often at the expense of ethical considerations.
The rapid pace of technological advancement, outpacing our ethical frameworks and creating new dilemmas.

Which of these scenarios from The Ethics of Freedom would you enjoy analyzing the most?

The Good Samaritan, exploring the motivations and implications of selfless action.
The Bird in the Cage, dissecting the limitations of defining freedom as mere absence of hindrance.
The General of the Army, grappling with the complexities of applying moral principles in difficult contexts.

When you think about the concept of free will, what are you most concerned about?

The potential for it to be an illusion, undermining our sense of agency and responsibility.
The burden of responsibility it places on us, if our choices truly shape our destiny.
The difficulty of reconciling free will with the many external factors that influence our lives.

What aspect of Professor Young’s philosophy makes you the most happy?

His emphasis on moral progress, offering a hopeful vision of human potential for growth.
His celebration of disinterested action, reminding us of the intrinsic rewards of ethical behavior.
His insightful critiques of other philosophers, encouraging us to think critically and form our own conclusions.

What is most likely to make you feel down about the challenges of living an ethical life in the modern world?

The seeming disconnect between moral ideals and the realities of a complex, often unjust world.
The pressure to conform to societal expectations, even when they conflict with personal values.
The constant bombardment of information and conflicting perspectives, making it difficult to discern right from wrong.

In a perfect world, what would ethical decision-making look like?

It would be guided by empathy, compassion, and a genuine desire for the well-being of all.
It would involve thoughtful deliberation, considering diverse perspectives and potential consequences.
It would be supported by a strong ethical framework, providing clear principles while allowing for nuance.

If you could wave a magic wand, what would the perfect outcome of the free will debate be?

A definitive answer that satisfies our desire for certainty, while still allowing for personal responsibility.
A greater understanding of the complexities, acknowledging both our agency and the influences shaping our choices.
A shift in focus from abstract debates to practical applications, using the insights to live more ethical lives.

How often do you engage in self-reflection about your own values and moral compass?

Regularly, it’s an integral part of my personal growth and development.
Occasionally, prompted by specific events or ethical dilemmas that arise.
Rarely, I tend to prioritize action over introspection.

You are at a party and a heated debate about a current ethical issue erupts, what do you do?

I actively participate, eager to share my perspective and engage in thoughtful discussion.
I listen intently, observing the different viewpoints and forming my own conclusions.
I try to steer the conversation towards common ground, seeking areas of agreement.

How comfortable are you with the idea that there might not be definitive answers to questions about free will and morality?

I’m perfectly comfortable with it, embracing the ambiguity and the ongoing search for meaning.
It makes me a bit uneasy, but I acknowledge the limitations of human understanding.
It’s frustrating, I crave certainty and struggle with the lack of clear-cut solutions.

You have a free afternoon to delve into any topic related to The Ethics of Freedom, what do you choose?

The historical context of Professor Young’s life and the philosophical debates of his time.
The practical applications of his ideas, exploring how to implement them in my own life.
The critiques of his work, seeking diverse perspectives and challenging my own understanding.

Which of these philosophical concepts from The Ethics of Freedom is most likely to be a struggle for you to fully grasp?

The intricacies of moral causation and its implications for free will.
The nuances of Kant’s “Categorical Imperative” and its application in ethical decision-making.
The distinction between true agency and the “Liberty of Indifference” Professor Young critiques.

Which member of Professor Young’s philosophy class are you?

The eager student, absorbing the information and engaging in lively discussions.
The skeptical inquirer, questioning assumptions and seeking deeper understanding.
The quiet observer, reflecting on the ideas presented and forming independent conclusions.

New information related to The Ethics of Freedom surfaces, challenging Professor Young’s views – what is your first response?

Curiosity, eager to explore the new evidence and reassess my understanding.
Skepticism, carefully evaluating the validity of the information and its potential biases.
Openness, willing to adjust my perspective based on new insights and perspectives.

Someone asks “How’s your moral compass doing these days?”, what’s the actual answer, not just “I’m good”?

“I’m actively working on it, striving to be more mindful and make choices aligned with my values.”
“It’s a constant work in progress, navigating the complexities of the world and my own moral development.”
“I’m facing some ethical dilemmas that have me questioning my beliefs and seeking deeper understanding.”

What’s your go-to source for expanding your knowledge and challenging your ethical perspectives?

Books, diving deep into philosophical texts and exploring diverse viewpoints.
Podcasts, engaging with contemporary discussions and hearing from experts in the field.
Conversations with others, valuing the exchange of ideas and the opportunity for shared learning.

What philosophical concept from The Ethics of Freedom do you most want to dive deep on and explore further?

The nature of the will and its various phases, as analyzed by Professor Young.
The limitations of intuitional moral principles and the role of reason in ethics.
The relationship between individual moral development and the potential for a more ethical society.

What’s your favorite memory related to learning about philosophy and ethics, whether from The Ethics of Freedom or elsewhere?

A thought-provoking discussion that challenged my assumptions and broadened my perspective.
A moment of clarity when a complex concept suddenly clicked and deepened my understanding.
The feeling of intellectual fulfillment that comes from grappling with important questions.

What ethical issues or philosophical questions are you most passionate about exploring?

Social justice, advocating for equality and fairness for all members of society.
Environmental ethics, considering our responsibility to the planet and future generations.
The ethics of technology, navigating the impact of artificial intelligence and other advancements.

What is your absolute favorite way to engage in philosophical reflection and ethical contemplation?

Losing myself in a thought-provoking book, highlighting key passages and taking notes.
Going for a long walk in nature, allowing my mind to wander and ideas to emerge.
Engaging in deep conversations with trusted friends or colleagues, sharing perspectives and learning from each other.

How would your friends and family describe your approach to ethics and morality?

Principled, standing up for what I believe in and striving to live by my values.
Thoughtful, considering different viewpoints and carefully weighing the potential consequences.
Compassionate, prioritizing empathy and seeking to understand the experiences of others.

Tell us a little about your personal philosophy on life and how it intersects with the ideas presented in The Ethics of Freedom?

I believe in personal responsibility, the pursuit of knowledge, and striving to make a positive impact.
I value authenticity, empathy, and the importance of living in accordance with my values.
I am drawn to philosophies that emphasize both individual agency and our interconnectedness with others.

If you could choose any one principle from The Ethics of Freedom to guide your life, which one would you choose and why?

The pursuit of the moral ideal, as it represents a continuous journey of growth and self-improvement.
The importance of disinterested action, as it reminds us to look beyond our own self-interest and act with compassion.
The belief in our capacity for moral development, as it offers hope for personal and societal progress.

What’s the first thing that comes to mind when you encounter a situation that challenges your ethical boundaries?

A sense of responsibility to act in accordance with my values, even if it’s difficult.
A desire to understand the different perspectives involved and the potential consequences of my actions.
A sense of unease, prompting me to reflect on the situation and seek guidance from trusted sources.

What type of ethical dilemma affects you the most – those involving personal relationships, social issues, or abstract philosophical concepts?

Dilemmas involving personal relationships, as they often involve conflicting loyalties and emotional complexities.
Dilemmas related to social issues, as they force me to confront injustice and consider my role in creating change.
Dilemmas rooted in abstract philosophical concepts, as they challenge my fundamental beliefs and understanding of the world.

What’s your idea of a truly ethical society – one governed by strict laws, individual moral compasses, or a balance of both?

A society that prioritizes education, fostering critical thinking and ethical awareness among its citizens.
A society that promotes empathy and compassion, encouraging individuals to consider the well-being of others.
A society that establishes a just legal framework while also empowering individuals to make ethical choices.

What is your strongest asset when it comes to navigating ethical dilemmas and striving to live a morally responsible life?

My unwavering commitment to my values, serving as a compass even in challenging situations.
My capacity for empathy, enabling me to understand and connect with the perspectives of others.
My willingness to learn and grow, constantly seeking new knowledge and refining my moral compass.

How prepared are you to face a complex ethical dilemma that challenges your deeply held beliefs?

I believe I possess the critical thinking skills and moral compass to navigate such challenges effectively.
While daunting, I am willing to engage in the necessary reflection and seek guidance when faced with such dilemmas.
Honestly, I feel unprepared and worry about making the “right” choice in such a high-stakes situation.

What happens if your actions, despite being motivated by good intentions, unintentionally harm others?

I would feel deep remorse and take responsibility for the unintended consequences of my actions.
While upsetting, I recognize that even well-intentioned actions can have unforeseen negative outcomes.
I would likely struggle with guilt and question my judgment, potentially becoming more hesitant in the future.

What do you think you need to develop further in your own life to be more aligned with the principles of The Ethics of Freedom?

Cultivating a more consistent practice of self-reflection to examine my motivations and actions.
Dedicating more time to studying ethical theories and engaging in thoughtful discussions on the subject.
Challenging myself to act more courageously on my values, even when facing social pressure or potential discomfort.

How often do you actively seek out opportunities to learn and grow your understanding of ethics and morality?

Frequently, I believe it’s an ongoing process of exploration and self-improvement.
Sporadically, often prompted by specific events or encounters that challenge my worldview.
Rarely, I tend to rely on my existing knowledge base and personal experiences.

How confident are you in your ability to identify and follow your moral compass, even when faced with difficult choices?

I trust my instincts and believe in my ability to make sound ethical decisions, even under pressure.
While I strive to stay true to my values, I acknowledge that external factors can sometimes cloud my judgment.
I often struggle with self-doubt and worry about making choices that contradict my moral compass.

How do you handle situations where your personal values clash with the expectations of your social group or authority figures?

I prioritize my values, even if it means disagreeing with others or challenging the status quo.
I try to find a compromise, balancing my principles with the need for harmony and respect for authority.
I tend to conform to the expectations of others, even if it creates internal conflict and a sense of dissonance.

Do you have a strong moral code present in all areas of your life, guiding your actions and interactions with others?

Yes, I strive to live by my values consistently, whether in personal relationships, professional settings, or public life.
I have a core set of principles, but I also recognize that context and specific situations can influence my choices.
I am still developing my moral code and exploring what values are most important to me.

How well do you stick to your convictions when faced with opposition or the potential for negative consequences?

I stand my ground, believing that compromising my values is not worth the price of conformity.
It depends on the situation, I weigh the potential risks and benefits before deciding whether to hold firm or adapt.
I often find it difficult to maintain my stance when faced with strong opposition or the threat of negative repercussions.

Which of the following is most accurate when it comes to your understanding of ethical theories and their practical applications?

I have a solid understanding of various ethical frameworks and can apply them to real-life situations.
I am familiar with some basic ethical principles, but I could benefit from further exploration and deeper understanding.
Ethics feels somewhat abstract to me, and I struggle to see how theoretical concepts translate into everyday life.

To what degree do you experience a sense of responsibility for the well-being of others, both those close to you and humanity as a whole?

I feel a strong sense of social responsibility and strive to make a positive impact on the world around me.
I care deeply about my loved ones and feel obligated to help those in need within my immediate circle.
While I believe in treating others with kindness, I tend to prioritize my own well-being and personal goals.

Which of these best describes your current approach to moral dilemmas and ethical decision-making?

I approach ethical challenges with careful consideration, weighing different perspectives and seeking ethical guidance when needed.
I tend to rely on intuition and personal experience, trusting my gut feeling to guide me toward the right course of action.
I often feel overwhelmed by ethical dilemmas and struggle to make decisions that align with my values.

What is your current biggest challenge when it comes to living an ethical and fulfilling life?

Balancing my own needs and desires with the responsibility I feel toward others.
Navigating a world that often seems at odds with my moral compass, where injustice and suffering are prevalent.
Overcoming self-doubt and fear of judgment, trusting myself to make difficult choices and stand by them.

What’s the first thing that comes to mind when you encounter a moral dilemma that has no easy answers?

A sense of curiosity, eager to unravel the complexities and explore different perspectives.
A feeling of discomfort, recognizing the weight of the decision and the potential for unintended consequences.
A desire to seek guidance from trusted sources, hoping to find clarity and support in navigating the ethical gray area.

How do you handle situations where you make a choice you later regret, realizing it contradicted your values or harmed others?

I strive to learn from my mistakes, taking responsibility for my actions and seeking to make amends where possible.
I can be hard on myself, dwelling on past mistakes and struggling to forgive myself for ethical missteps.
I try to move on quickly, focusing on the present and future rather than dwelling on past regrets.

How would you describe your relationship to the concept of “the greater good” – is it something you prioritize, or do you lean towards individual liberties?

I believe in finding a balance between individual freedom and the well-being of society as a whole.
I prioritize individual liberties, trusting that a society that respects autonomy will ultimately lead to greater good.
I lean towards prioritizing the greater good, even if it means some limitations on individual freedoms for the benefit of all.

Are you stuck in any patterns of behavior or thinking that you recognize as ethically questionable or misaligned with your values?

I strive for self-awareness and actively work to identify and address any areas where my actions contradict my values.
I have blind spots, and there might be patterns I’m not fully conscious of that could benefit from further reflection.
I believe my actions generally align with my moral compass, and I’m not overly concerned about unconscious ethical inconsistencies.

What would you say are your top struggles right now when it comes to living in accordance with your ethical principles?

Resisting the pressure to conform to societal expectations that clash with my personal values.
Overcoming fear of judgment or negative consequences that can make it tempting to stay silent in the face of injustice.
Maintaining consistency in my actions, ensuring that my behavior reflects my values even in small, everyday interactions.

What is your ultimate goal when it comes to your own moral development and journey towards living an ethical and meaningful life?

To become a beacon of compassion and integrity, inspiring others to live by their values and contribute to a more just world.
To find peace of mind, knowing that my actions are aligned with my principles and contribute to the well-being of others.
To continually learn and grow, embracing the complexities of ethics and striving to make choices that reflect my evolving understanding.

What do you think is missing in your life right now that could support your commitment to ethical living and moral growth?

A stronger support system of like-minded individuals who share my values and can offer guidance and accountability.
More opportunities to engage in meaningful conversations about ethics and explore different perspectives on complex issues.
Greater courage to act on my convictions, even when facing potential backlash or discomfort.

What is your current level of expertise when it comes to understanding and applying different ethical frameworks?

I have a strong foundation in ethical theory and can confidently analyze dilemmas using various perspectives.
I have a basic understanding of ethics, but I would benefit from expanding my knowledge and exploring different frameworks.
Ethics feels somewhat foreign to me, and I often struggle to grasp the nuances of different philosophical perspectives.

A friend asks for your opinion on a moral dilemma they’re facing. How do you respond?

I listen attentively, ask clarifying questions, and offer my perspective while encouraging them to trust their own judgment.
I share my immediate opinion, drawing on my own experiences and values to provide guidance and support.
I hesitate to offer advice, feeling unequipped to provide counsel on such a weighty matter.

What descriptive word best encapsulates the emotional state you experience most frequently when confronted with ethical challenges – curiosity, anxiety, or inspiration?

Curiosity, as I see ethical dilemmas as opportunities for growth and deeper understanding.
Anxiety, as I feel the weight of responsibility and fear making the “wrong” choice.
Inspiration, as I am motivated to act on my values and contribute to a more just and compassionate world.

Which of the following do you notice yourself worrying about on a day-to-day basis – fulfilling your responsibilities, making ethical choices, or pursuing your passions?

I worry most about fulfilling my responsibilities, ensuring that I meet my obligations to myself and others.
I am most concerned with making ethical choices, striving to live in accordance with my values in all aspects of my life.
I prioritize pursuing my passions, believing that finding fulfillment in my endeavors will naturally lead to ethical behavior.

How confident and grounded do you feel in your own moral compass and your ability to navigate the complexities of right and wrong?

I feel confident and grounded, trusting my instincts and believing in the strength of my ethical foundation.
I experience moments of both confidence and uncertainty, recognizing that moral development is an ongoing journey.
I often feel uncertain and swayed by external influences, struggling to fully trust my own judgment.

How well do you believe you balance the pursuit of personal happiness with the responsibility to contribute to the well-being of others?

I believe in a harmonious balance, recognizing that my own happiness is intertwined with the happiness of those around me.
I tend to prioritize personal happiness, trusting that by pursuing my own fulfillment, I will naturally contribute to the world.
I often prioritize the needs of others over my own, sometimes neglecting my own well-being in the process.

How connected do you feel to your own intuition and inner wisdom when faced with ethical dilemmas, or do you rely more on external guidance?

I trust my intuition and believe it provides valuable insights, even when those insights challenge conventional wisdom.
I listen to my gut feeling but also seek external guidance, valuing diverse perspectives and ethical frameworks.
I struggle to connect with my intuition and often feel more comfortable relying on external rules or advice.

Which of the following is most likely to frustrate you in your quest to live an ethical life – hypocrisy in others, your own shortcomings, or the complexities of moral dilemmas?

I am most frustrated by hypocrisy in others, especially when those in positions of power preach ethics but fail to practice them.
I can be hard on myself, and my own shortcomings and inconsistencies often cause me the most frustration.
The complexities of moral dilemmas, where there are no easy answers, are the most frustrating aspect of ethical decision-making for me.

What is the trickiest part about making ethical choices in your professional life, where factors like competition and profit can sometimes clash with moral principles?

Balancing my desire for success with my commitment to ethical conduct, especially when those two goals seem at odds.
Speaking up against unethical practices within my workplace, even when it feels risky or could jeopardize my position.
Navigating a culture that prioritizes profit over people, making it challenging to advocate for ethical considerations.

Do you struggle more with setting clear ethical boundaries or with upholding those boundaries when faced with pressure or temptation?

I struggle more with setting clear boundaries, as I tend to be accommodating and want to avoid conflict.
I find it more challenging to uphold boundaries when faced with pressure, as I can be swayed by persuasive arguments or fear of consequences.
I am generally comfortable with both setting and maintaining my ethical boundaries.

Do you have a strong support system in place, such as a mentor, therapist, or close friends, to help you navigate ethical challenges and stay true to your values?

Yes, I have a network of trusted individuals I can confide in and seek guidance from when facing ethical dilemmas.
I have a few close friends or family members I can talk to, but I don’t necessarily have a dedicated support system for ethical matters.
I prefer to navigate ethical challenges independently, relying on my own judgment and moral compass.

How do you determine your personal ethical priorities each day?

I reflect on my values and strive to align my actions with my principles in all aspects of my life.
I consider the potential consequences of my choices, aiming to minimize harm and maximize well-being for myself and others.
I adapt to the circumstances, making decisions based on the specific context and what feels right in the moment.

Are your actions consistently achieving your desired ethical outcomes, or do you sometimes face unintended consequences or moral compromises?

I strive for consistency and am generally pleased with the ethical outcomes of my choices, though I recognize that no one is perfect.
I experience both successes and setbacks, learning from my mistakes and striving to make more informed ethical decisions in the future.
I often face unintended consequences or feel compelled to compromise my values, which can lead to feelings of guilt or dissonance.

How do you manage the emotional and psychological impact of confronting ethical dilemmas, especially those that involve difficult choices or potential conflicts with others?

I have healthy coping mechanisms in place, such as mindfulness practices, journaling, or seeking support from trusted individuals.
I tend to process ethical challenges internally, which can sometimes lead to rumination or anxiety.
I try to avoid dwelling on ethical dilemmas, preferring to focus on more positive aspects of my life.

Learn more