The Scientific Evidence of Organic Evolution Informative Summary


George Romanes’s 1882 essay, “The Scientific Evidences of Organic Evolution,” presents a concise argument in favor of Darwin’s theory of evolution by natural selection. The essay delves into a range of scientific evidence, arguing that the concept of separate creation is far less probable than the theory of descent with modification. Romanes dismantles the traditional arguments for intelligent design, emphasizing the importance of the “law of parsimony” in scientific reasoning—that simpler explanations should be preferred over more complex ones. He meticulously analyzes the evidence from classification, morphology, geology, geographical distribution, embryology, and broader considerations to illustrate the consistency of evolutionary theory with the observed world.

Romanes expertly addresses common objections to evolution, such as the lack of direct observation of species transmutation. He argues that the weight of accumulated evidence makes the theory of evolution highly probable, even if it remains technically a theory and not a proven fact. He further counters the emotional argument of man’s supposed “degradation” through evolution, emphasizing that scientific progress often challenges established notions of dignity, and that the complexity of human resemblance to apes points towards a shared ancestry rather than arbitrary design.

Key Findings:

  • Scientific classification: The tree-like organization of species, reflecting their structural affinities, strongly suggests genetic relationships.
  • Morphology: Variations in the same structures (like the arm) across different species, along with the presence of rudimentary organs, support the idea of descent with modification.
  • Geology: The absence of highly-organized fossils in early geological strata, combined with the gradual progression of complexity in the fossil record, supports the theory of evolution.
  • Geographical Distribution: The similarity of species on continents and islands with shared historical connections and the stark differences between geographically isolated regions point to the influence of geographic barriers on evolutionary pathways.
  • Embryology: The shared developmental stages of different animals, including the presence of rudimentary structures in higher animals, suggests common ancestry.
  • General Considerations: Evolutionary theory provides explanations for instincts and aspects of human psychology (sympathy, reason, conscience), and it offers a better explanation for imperfections in organisms than the theory of intelligent design.


  • The Power of Natural Selection: The reader will gain a deeper understanding of natural selection as a driving force of evolution. Natural selection favors organisms best suited to their environment, leading to gradual changes over time as environmental conditions change.
  • Rudimentary Organs: This text will explain the significance of rudimentary organs. These non-functional or reduced structures (like the human tailbone) are remnants of organs that were functional in ancestors. They serve as evidence of evolutionary lineage.
  • Evolutionary History: The essay explores how the history of life is evident in the distribution of organisms across geographical areas and through time (as seen in the fossil record). The similarities and differences between species in different regions reveal patterns of migration and isolation, highlighting the role of geography in evolution.
  • Embryological Development: The reader will gain insight into the interconnectedness of life through embryology. The development of higher animals mirrors the stages of simpler organisms, demonstrating a shared evolutionary history.
  • The Law of Parsimony: Romanes emphasizes the importance of using the simplest explanation that adequately accounts for the observed phenomena. He argues that natural selection, being a simpler and more parsimonious explanation, is more likely to be true than the theory of separate creation.

Historical Context:

Romanes wrote his essay in 1882, a period when Darwin’s theory of evolution was still facing significant resistance from the scientific and religious communities. Romanes aimed to present a clear and concise argument for the theory, targeting audiences who may not have been familiar with Darwin’s work. His essay reflects the state of scientific understanding at the time, highlighting the growing body of evidence in support of evolution and the weakening of arguments for special creation.


  1. More organisms are born than can survive: Due to limited resources, a constant “struggle for existence” occurs, leading to natural selection.
  2. Survival of the fittest: Individuals with advantageous traits are more likely to survive and reproduce, passing those traits to their offspring.
  3. Whales and porpoises are aquatic mammals: Their evolution from terrestrial ancestors is evident in their skeletal structure, with modified limbs for swimming and rudimentary hind legs.
  4. Bats are the only flying mammals: Their wings, evolved from forelimbs, are a striking example of adaptation to flight.
  5. Snakes lack limbs: Their limbless condition, along with other modifications, indicates a long evolutionary history of adaptation to their environment.
  6. The horse evolved from a five-toed ancestor: The presence of splint bones in the modern horse’s leg is a reminder of its evolutionary journey.
  7. The geological record shows a gradual increase in complexity of life: This pattern, from simple organisms in early strata to more complex ones in later strata, supports evolution.
  8. Oceanic islands often have unique species: Their isolation has led to the evolution of distinct species that are not found elsewhere.
  9. The Galapagos Islands show variation within a group: The close relationship of species on different islands in the Galapagos Archipelago compared to their relationship with mainland South America supports the concept of isolation leading to new species.
  10. Frogs, toads, and newts are absent from oceanic islands: Their inability to survive saltwater travel explains their absence from these islands.
  11. Bats are the only mammals found on islands more than 300 miles from mainland: This reinforces the importance of migratory capability in explaining species distribution.
  12. Some plants have adaptations for seed dispersal by mammals: These adaptations are perplexing in islands without mammals, suggesting evolution based on past conditions.
  13. The Malay Archipelago shows a distinct division of species: A deep water channel separating islands reflects the evolutionary divergence of species across the archipelago.
  14. The depth of the sea between islands correlates with species differences: This observation, inexplicable by separate creation, supports the theory of isolation influencing evolution.
  15. Artificial transportation of species often results in success: This demonstrates that species can thrive in new environments, challenging the idea of strict geographical allocation by design.
  16. The human embryo exhibits traits of lower vertebrates: These early developmental stages, including gill slits, a tail, and a cloacal passage, point towards a shared ancestry with fish, reptiles, and amphibians.
  17. The human heart starts as a simple vessel, similar to the lowest fishes: This embryological similarity supports the evolutionary link between humans and less complex organisms.
  18. Human embryos have a tail longer than their legs: This provides a visible example of developmental resemblance to other vertebrates.
  19. Human embryos have a thick coat of hair, except for the palms and soles: This corresponds to the naked undersides of limbs in many lower animals.
  20. The great toe of a human embryo projects at an angle, resembling the permanent condition in primates: This anatomical detail supports the evolutionary connection between humans and apes.


  1. Millions of mechanisms and instincts in the animal kingdom: This vast number of complex adaptations makes it difficult to accept that they were all separately designed.
  2. The eye, though complex, is not optically perfect: This imperfection in an intricate structure points towards an evolutionary origin rather than perfect design.
  3. Thousands of specific forms of life: The vast diversity of life revealed through paleontology supports the theory of descent with modification.
  4. The Galapagos Archipelago is over 500 miles from South America: This distance highlights the importance of isolation in the evolution of unique species on the islands.
  5. Oceanic islands are over 300 miles from land: This distance explains the absence of most mammals from these islands, reinforcing the influence of geographical barriers.
  6. The Malay Archipelago has a deep water channel: This channel, reflecting a past separation, explains the distinct species on each side.
  7. The West Indian islands stand on a deeply submerged bank: This isolation explains the distinct species found there, despite their proximity to mainland America.
  8. Human embryos are approximately an inch long: This stage of development showcases crucial evolutionary markers, like the angled great toe.
  9. Thousands of cases of adaptation exist in nature: The pervasiveness of adaptive mechanisms across the animal kingdom lends weight to the theory of natural selection.
  10. The human brain is remarkably similar to the brains of higher apes: This similarity strongly suggests shared ancestry.
  11. Millions of years of geological history: This immense time scale is necessary for the gradual changes of evolution to occur.
  12. Over 1,000 fathoms deep: The depth of the submerged bank under the West Indies islands underlines the barrier to species movement and the influence of isolation on evolution.
  13. Five hundred miles: The distance between the Galapagos Islands and mainland South America underscores the importance of isolation in evolution.
  14. Thirty miles: The distance between the islands in the Galapagos Archipelago illustrates how close proximity allows for less variation compared to the distance from the mainland.
  15. Fifteen times: This ratio represents the difference in distance between the Galapagos Islands and South America compared to the distance between the islands themselves, highlighting the influence of isolation.
  16. Numerous hooks on seed pods: These hooks, designed for dispersal by mammals, highlight adaptations that are perplexing in islands without mammals.
  17. Hundreds and hundreds of cases of adaptive modification: The widespread occurrence of adaptations across many species points to the efficiency of natural selection.
  18. Three hundred miles: This distance, as a critical threshold for mammalian migration, highlights the importance of geographical barriers.
  19. Over a thousand fathoms deep: The depth of the sea between islands in the Malay Archipelago, highlighting the influence of geographic barriers on the distribution of species.
  20. A vast body of evidence: This reinforces the strength of the argument for evolution, demonstrating the consistency of the theory across many scientific disciplines.


  • Natural Selection: The process by which organisms better adapted to their environment tend to survive and reproduce more successfully.
  • Survival of the fittest: A phrase coined by Herbert Spencer to describe the process of natural selection.
  • Species: A group of organisms that can interbreed and produce fertile offspring.
  • Genus: A taxonomic rank that includes similar species.
  • Morphology: The study of the form and structure of organisms.
  • Rudimentary Organs: Non-functional or reduced structures that were once functional in ancestral organisms.
  • Paleontology: The study of fossils.
  • Geographical Distribution: The pattern of where species are found on Earth.
  • Oceanic Islands: Islands formed by volcanic activity or other geological processes, not connected to continents.
  • Embryology: The study of the development of organisms.


  1. The whale: Its streamlined body, modified limbs for swimming, and rudimentary hind legs are evidence of its aquatic adaptation and descent from terrestrial ancestors.
  2. The bat: Its wings, formed from elongated fingers and a membranous web, demonstrate adaptation to flight.
  3. Snakes: The absence of limbs in snakes, except for tiny remnants in the python, provides evidence of evolutionary change.
  4. The horse: Its single toe and splint bones reflect the evolution of this animal from a five-toed ancestor.
  5. The Galapagos Archipelago: The variation of species within the Galapagos Islands compared to mainland South America shows the role of isolation in evolution.
  6. The Malay Archipelago: The distinct species on either side of a deep water channel in the Malay Archipelago demonstrate how geographic barriers affect evolution.
  7. The human embryo: Its development reveals features of fish, reptiles, and amphibians, showcasing evolutionary ties to these ancestral forms.
  8. The human heart: Its early development reflects the simple, pulsating heart of fish, further supporting evolutionary history.
  9. Human embryos with tails: These tails, which disappear before birth, are remnants of structures found in ancestral vertebrates.
  10. The human eye: Its imperfection, even when considered an optical instrument, indicates that it evolved through natural processes rather than being perfectly designed.


Romanes’s essay presents a compelling argument for Darwin’s theory of evolution by natural selection. The evidence he presents from various fields of science, including classification, morphology, geology, geographical distribution, and embryology, consistently points towards the theory of descent with modification. Romanes expertly dismantles the arguments for special creation, demonstrating the illogical nature of such explanations and highlighting the scientific power of natural selection. While acknowledging the emotional objections that some may have to evolution, Romanes emphasizes that scientific progress often challenges preconceived notions of dignity and that the vast body of evidence overwhelmingly supports the theory of evolution.

Learn more

What is the best quiz for you business?

Quizzes are super effective for lead generation and selling products. Find the best quiz for your business by answering a few questions.

Take the quiz